Cut a pomegranate in half the week before Thanksgiving and hold it up to your nose, and you will smell almost nothing. The seeds burst sharp and sweet on your tongue, yet the fruit gives very little scent to the air. Apples do a little better, though a bowl of them on the counter only reaches you when you lean in close.
What customers say on Google
View on Google
So almost every pomegranate apple candle on a shelf this month is a fragrance built from other notes, picked to make your nose read tart red fruit sitting on warm spice. That matters when the candle is a gift for the person cooking your dinner, because the label on the jar tells you much less than the list of notes does. It is the reason we send Thanksgiving gift buyers to the fruit and spice blends in our hand-poured beeswax candle collection, where every note is printed and the wax is a single ingredient.
The jar everyone grabs, and why it lets the host down
The easy answer is the red three-wick jar by the register, the one that smells wonderful with the lid off. It is the first gift most people think of, and it looks right on a fall table.
The trouble starts once it burns at home. Buyers who review these candles complain most about a sweetness that tastes like hard candy, and about wax that sinks down the middle while the sides stay solid.
Both problems have a cause you can follow. When a fruit accord is thin, makers often turn up the sugar notes to fill the gap. Sweet notes travel well off a cold jar in a store aisle, so the candle sells, but once the wax melts the sugar takes over the room.
The sinking middle is called tunneling. A wick too small for its jar melts only a narrow pool, so each burn digs a little deeper and leaves a wall of unused wax behind.
Then there is the wax itself, and it takes a few steps to see what it is. Crude oil goes to a refinery to become gasoline and diesel. A waxy residue is left over once that work is done, and it gets filtered and bleached until it turns white.
That residue is paraffin, which makes paraffin petroleum waste. Many big holiday jars use it alone or blended into soy. When paraffin burns with a flickering flame, it can leave black soot on the rim of the jar and on the wall above it.
None of this shows in the store. Your host finds it on Friday morning, looking at a gray jar with a crater in the center, which is why the next question matters more than the label.
What pomegranate apple smells like once you take it apart
Strip the label off and these blends come in two halves. The top half is bright and tart, the snap you get from red berries or a squeeze of citrus peel. The bottom half is warm and slow, usually vanilla with baking spice under it.
The tart half is what makes the scent feel like late fall instead of deep winter. The warm half is what makes it feel like a holiday at all. Every pomegranate apple candle is some balance of the two, and the person you are shopping for almost always leans toward one side.
Think about whose house you are heading to on Thursday. Maybe she keeps a bowl of clementines on the counter and sneaks cranberries into the stuffing. She loves the tart half, and for her our Retail Therapy beeswax candle goes straight to that bright red-fruit place.
It opens on red currant and black currant, two small berries with the same sour snap a pomegranate seed has on your tongue. Under the berries sit peach and jasmine, with amber and tonka bean keeping the base warm. The full list of notes reads: Red Currant, Black Currant, Jasmine, Peach, Black Tea, Amber, Anise, Tonka Bean.
The name on the jar says nothing about pomegranate. Even so, it lands right where those candles are aiming, and it gets there with one wax and a wooden wick.
Before you choose a scent, choose the room it will burn in
A Thanksgiving kitchen already has a strong smell of its own. Roast turkey and sage stuffing fill it from noon on, and the oven door opens every twenty minutes.
A fruit candle on the dinner table has to fight that, and the food wins. The table is also the busiest spot in the house, crowded with napkins and serving dishes, which makes it the worst place for an open flame.
The better spots are the entryway, where guests walk in from the cold, and the living room, where everyone waits while the turkey rests. A scent there greets people first, then fades into the background once they sit down to eat.
The room also tells you the size. A big open living room with people moving through it all afternoon needs a wide pool of melted wax, and two wicks melt a wider pool than one. A small kitchen or an entry nook fills easily with a single wick.
So you now have the two questions that decide the gift. Which half of the scent does she love, and which room will she light it in?
The best pomegranate apple candles for Thanksgiving, matched to the person hosting
These are ranked from the host you know best to the one who is new at it, because the newest host is the one who will lean on the gift hardest.
For the host who cooks the whole meal: Retail Therapy, 80-hour size
This is the friend who brines the turkey on Tuesday and owns a second oven thermometer. She hosts in a living room big enough for twelve, and she wants the house to smell festive before anyone smells food.
Retail Therapy gives her the tart half of the pomegranate apple blend, berry-bright on top with a warm amber base. Bring the 12 oz size, which has two wooden wicks and burns 80+ hours, for $65. Two wicks matter in her room because they melt the whole surface faster, and a full melt pool is what pushes scent into a large space.
Picture her on Wednesday night, table half set, lighting it on the side table while the pies cool. On Thursday her guests come through the door into red fruit and warm amber. By Sunday the dishes are done and she lights it again, with plenty of hours left for the rest of the season.
"This scent has me in a chokehold. I burn it in my room and my living room and it fills my space SOOOOO nicely... Theres nothing I hate more than a candle that can't fill the room and baby this is NOT that. This candle permeates every corner of the room."
Tiffany Gordon, on Retail Therapy
For the relative who brings the pies: People Watching, 40-hour size
Every family has one. She shows up with two pies and a tin of cookies, and her apartment smells like cinnamon from October to January. She loves the warm half of the blend, the spiced cider side of pomegranate apple.
Our People Watching beeswax candle lives right there. It starts with lemon and orange zest, then settles into warm baking spice over thick vanilla. The notes are: Lemon, Orange, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Clove, Nutmeg, Allspice, Ginger.
Her kitchen is small, so the 5 oz size fits it well, with one wooden wick and 40 hours of burn, for $32. One wick fills a galley kitchen without crowding it, and she can keep it on the counter while she rolls out dough.
On the Monday after Thanksgiving, she sits down with a slice of leftover pie and a cup of coffee. The candle crackles on the windowsill, and her place smells the way her pies taste.
"I love this candle. I burn it everyday and my whole place smells AMAZING."
Jessica H., on People Watching
For the first-time host: one of each, one per room
The friend hosting her first Thanksgiving is nervous about the turkey and has not thought about how the house will smell. Give her both, with a note saying where each one goes.
People Watching goes in the entry, so guests walk into warm spice. Retail Therapy goes in the living room, where the tart fruit keeps the space bright during the long wait before dinner.
Each room carries its own scent, so the two never blur together. She gets the whole pomegranate apple feeling split across her home, and she gets to hear guests ask what she is burning.
Why a beeswax candle lasts through the whole holiday weekend
Thanksgiving runs four days for most hosts, from Wednesday prep to Sunday cleanup. A gift that burns out by Friday misses most of it, so burn time is part of the gift.
Beeswax has the highest melting point of any common candle wax. A harder wax melts more slowly under the flame, which is why the 12 oz size runs 80+ hours. Every MBur candle is 100% beeswax, one ingredient with nothing blended in, and it comes from the hive as a byproduct of honey.
The wooden wick is the part your host will notice first. Wood burns with a soft crackle and a wide, steady flame, and that wide flame helps the wax melt evenly out toward the edges of the jar.
The fragrance is phthalate-free, and there is no chemical dye in the wax. The golden color comes from the beeswax itself. Each candle is hand poured in New York City.
One more detail suits late November. Beeswax gives off a light closest to natural sunlight, a warm gold glow that looks right in a house where it gets dark before five.
A few things you might still be weighing
"But she asked for pomegranate apple by name."
Then give her the tart half, because that is the part people mean when they ask for it. Retail Therapy's red currant and black currant carry the same sour red-fruit snap, and the 80-hour size suits a host with a big room.
"Her house will smell like dinner anyway."
It will, for about three hours. The candle fills the hours before guests sit down and the long evening after, when the kitchen is closed and everyone is back on the couch.
"She already has a shelf full of candles."
Most hosts do. A 100% beeswax candle with a wooden wick will burn differently from whatever else is on that shelf. The real question is which scent she does not own yet, so pick the half of the blend that matches her cooking.
How to present it so it gets lit on Thursday
Hand it over when you arrive, before the meal. A gift given at the door can go straight into the living room before guests settle in. A gift given at 10 p.m. usually goes in a cupboard.
Set it on a small saucer with a pomegranate cut in half beside it. The red seeds look festive next to the gold wax, and they tie the gift to the scent she asked for. Pomegranates and apples are classic Thanksgiving decor, so the pairing reads as part of her table.
Skip the cellophane and add a card with one line on it saying which room and when. "Light this in the living room while the turkey rests" tells her exactly what to do. A second line can ask her to let the first burn melt all the way to the edges, since that first pool sets the shape of every burn after it.
Questions people ask before they bring a candle to Thanksgiving
Can I burn a fruity candle while the turkey is in the oven?
Yes, as long as it is in a different room from the food. Put it in the entry or the living room so the two scents do not mix at the table. A warm spice blend like People Watching sits well near cooking smells because it shares the baking spice in a pie.
How far should a candle sit from the centerpiece and napkins?
Keep a burning candle at least 12 inches from napkins and anything else that can catch fire. The National Fire Protection Association's safety education pages cover this and other basics. Trim each wick to a quarter inch before every burn, which keeps the flame on Retail Therapy's two wooden wicks steady and even.
Which size should I bring as a hostess gift?
Match it to the room. The 12 oz size with two wicks suits a large living room or a host who lights candles most nights. The 5 oz size with one wick suits a small kitchen or an entry. If you are unsure, the 12 oz Retail Therapy candle is the one for a host who entertains often.
What if my host loves hotel-style scents more than fruit?
Then reach for Room Service, our bestselling beeswax candle. Its notes are Saffron, White Tea, Purple Peonies, Orchid, Tobacco, Vanilla, Almond Milk, Tonka Bean, and it is the scent people pick for a room where they host.
The pick for your Thanksgiving host
The smell people call pomegranate apple is tart red fruit over warm spice, so the best gift is the half your host already loves. Place it in the room where guests gather, away from the dinner table, and choose a candle that burns evenly all weekend.
For most hosts, that is the 80-hour Retail Therapy. It makes her living room feel bright and ready before the first guest rings the bell. The red currant and black currant give the tart snap she is after, and the two wooden wicks melt a pool wide enough for a big room. As Tiffany Gordon put it, "This candle permeates every corner of the room."
Each candle is hand poured in New York City, so order this week to have it in your hands before you leave for dinner.
Related reading
