Home / MBur blog

Best Candles That Smell Like Yankee Candle Bayside Cedar: 5 Picks Ranked by How Close They Get

You love the rainy cedar smell of Yankee Candle Bayside Cedar, and you want to know which candle gets closest to it. Of the five candles ranked below, the best match shares Bayside Cedar's pear and bergamot opening and its warm amber base. It also burns on 100% beeswax with wooden wicks.

What customers say on Google
View on Google

Our top pick is Do Not Disturb, because it lands the same juicy fruit over soft wood that makes Bayside Cedar so easy to live with. Our second pick brings the cedarwood forward for readers who bought the Yankee jar for the wood. Both come from MBur's line of pure beeswax candles hand poured in New York City.

What Bayside Cedar smells like, and the two parts a match has to copy

Yankee Candle built Bayside Cedar around the idea of a forest path after a fresh rain. Its published notes fall into three layers:

  • Top: Bergamot, Green Pear, Grapefruit
  • Middle: Mandarin Blossom, Water Lily
  • Base: Amber, Cedarwood, Musk

Read that list from the top and you can see why the name surprises people. The cedar sits at the very bottom. What reaches you first is cold fruit and a citrus bite, which is why the candle smells like spring woods after a storm.

Fans often confuse it with heavier winter candles, including Yankee's own Balsam & Cedar. Those lean on pine resin and deep evergreen. The Bayside Cedar scent stays light and a little watery, and the wood holds everything up from underneath.

So a real match has to copy two things. It needs that bright fruit at the top, and it needs warm wood and amber at the base to hold it. A candle that only gets the cedar right will remind you of a different candle. Once you know the target, the next question is what the scent burns on.

The wax underneath decides how that scent reaches your room

Fragrance in a candle rides on the melted pool of wax. The flame heats the pool, the fragrance oil lifts off the surface, and the scent drifts into the room. Change the wax and you change how long the scent lasts and what else comes off the flame.

Most mass-market jar candles start with paraffin, so it helps to know where paraffin comes from. A refinery heats crude oil and splits it into products like gasoline and motor oil. While the motor oil is being cleaned up, a waxy residue gets pulled out of it. That leftover residue is paraffin.

So paraffin is petroleum waste with fragrance added. When it burns, it tends to leave black soot. You can see it as a gray ring inside the jar, and sometimes as a shadow on the wall above. Soot forms when fuel does not burn all the way, and the unburned carbon floats off as fine black specks.

Beeswax starts somewhere else entirely. Bees make it to build their comb, and beekeepers collect it as a byproduct of honey. It is a single ingredient, and it has the highest melting point of any candle wax. A higher melting point means the pool forms slowly and the candle burns longer, which is why MBur's 12 oz size runs 80+ hours.

The fragrance matters as much as the wax. Many candles use toxic fragrances made with phthalates, which are chemicals added to help a scent cling and last. MBur uses only phthalate-free fragrance and no chemical dye. With the wax and fragrance settled, the only open question is which scent gets you closest to Bayside Cedar.

The 5 best candles that smell like Yankee Candle Bayside Cedar

The ranking follows one rule: how many of Bayside Cedar's notes a candle shares, and how cleanly it burns them. Picks one and two are the closest matches. Picks three to five show where other well-known woods candles land, so you can see why the top two hold their spots if you want an alternative to Yankee Candle that keeps the scent you love.

1. MBur Do Not Disturb: the closest match, note for note

Picture a pear cold from the refrigerator door, sliced on the counter while a cup of Earl Grey steeps next to it. That pear and the bergamot in the tea are the first two notes of Bayside Cedar. They are also the opening of our Do Not Disturb pure beeswax candle.

Its full notes are Pear, Bergamot, Peach Blossom, Amber, Jasmine, Vanilla, Sandalwood. Peach blossom plays the role that mandarin blossom plays in Bayside Cedar, a soft floral in the middle. Amber anchors the base in both. Sandalwood gives the same dry wood floor as cedar, with a creamier edge that suits a room you wind down in.

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, one on the 5 oz and two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz) or 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none

Standout feature: it shares Bayside Cedar's pear and bergamot top and its amber base, the notes you smell first and the one that lingers.
Best for: a bedroom, or any room you light most nights.
Size and price: the 12 oz, 80-hour size ($65), because two wooden wicks melt a full, even pool on a candle you will light again and again.

The scent stays soft enough to sleep near and still carries into the next room. One buyer put it this way:

"I love the scent of this candle. It is lovely not overpowering. It's soothing fragrance more than covers my bedroom and bathroom."

Verified buyer, Do Not Disturb

2. MBur Touch Grass: the cedar-forward match

Some people buy Bayside Cedar for the wood. If that is you, think of a garden right after rain, when you brush past wet stems and the air smells green and a little bitter. That is the opening of our Touch Grass pure beeswax candle, and from there the base moves straight into cedar.

Its full notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean. Galbanum is a green resin from a plant in the carrot family, and it smells like a snapped stem. Cedarwood and amber are the same pair at the base of Bayside Cedar, so the dry-down lands somewhere familiar.

Readers searching for a natural woodsy fragrance usually mean this: wood that smells like the outdoors after weather has passed through. Touch Grass keeps that green, wet edge on top of the cedar.

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, one on the 5 oz and two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz) or 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none

Standout feature: cedarwood and amber in the base, with a wet green top that echoes the after-rain idea behind Bayside Cedar.
Best for: a home office or an entryway, anywhere you want the outdoors brought inside.
Size and price: the 5 oz, 40-hour size ($32), because one wooden wick fills a smaller room evenly.

3. Maison Louis Marie No.04 Bois de Balincourt

Maison Louis Marie built its name on quiet, earthy fragrances with a French country feel. No.04 is its best-known woods scent, centered on sandalwood and cedarwood. It echoes Bayside Cedar's woody base more than its bright fruit top.

That difference matters if the pear and citrus are what drew you to Bayside Cedar in the first place. Readers who want the wood with a fresh opening still in place land on Touch Grass, which pairs cedarwood and amber with a wet-garden top on 100% beeswax.

4. Boy Smells St. Al

Boy Smells is a design-forward brand known for bold, modern scent pairings and colorful jars. St. Al leans warm and sensual, with a woody, clay-like character. It sits closer to the late-evening end of Bayside Cedar than to its fresh, rainy start.

If what you love most is the warm amber and musk that settle in at night, Do Not Disturb gives you a warm amber base and keeps the pear and bergamot on top. You get the evening mood and the opening you already know.

5. Village Candle Balsam & Cedar

Village Candle is a long-running American brand with a traditional, homey style. Its Balsam & Cedar sits in the evergreen family, built around fir balsam and wood. This is the heavier winter profile that people often mix up with Bayside Cedar.

It earns a place here because the two names sound so alike. Bayside Cedar is a spring scent at heart, light and watery. For that lightness, the top two picks on this list are the ones to reach for.

The five side by side

Candle Scent lean What it shares with Bayside Cedar
1. MBur Do Not Disturb Fresh fruit over soft wood Pear and bergamot top, soft blossom middle, amber base
2. MBur Touch Grass Wet green garden over cedar Cedarwood and amber base, after-rain green top
3. Maison Louis Marie No.04 Earthy woods Woody base
4. Boy Smells St. Al Warm, sensual woods Warm evening base
5. Village Candle Balsam & Cedar Winter evergreen Cedar in the name, heavier style

The top two share more of Bayside Cedar than anything else on the list. Which one you take home depends on the room you plan to light it in.

Matching the scent and the size to your room

Bayside Cedar fans tend to burn it in one room on repeat. Start there, because the room decides both the scent and the size.

A bedroom you light most nights

Choose Do Not Disturb in the 12 oz size. The pear and bergamot read fresh at the start of the evening, and the sandalwood and vanilla settle in as you get ready for bed. Two wooden wicks keep the melt pool even night after night.

A large open living room or kitchen

Pick the 12 oz in either scent. Two wicks melt a wider pool, and a wider pool releases more fragrance into a big space. For a room where people gather, the fruit opening of Do Not Disturb feels bright and welcoming.

A small room you use now and then

The 5 oz size, with one wooden wick and 40 hours of burn, is sized for a home office or a bathroom. Touch Grass fits here when you want the cedar to come through.

If strong scents bother you

Go with Do Not Disturb. Buyers describe it as lovely and not overpowering. Beeswax melts slowly, so the scent builds gradually as the pool widens.

What Bayside Cedar fans ask before they switch

"My Yankee jar fills the whole floor. Will beeswax keep up?"

Scent throw comes from the size of the melt pool and the fragrance in it. That is why the 12 oz size carries two wooden wicks, so the pool reaches the edges and the whole surface releases scent. One verified buyer wrote that MBur candles "smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out."

"The cedar is the part I love most."

Then Touch Grass is your scent. Its cedarwood and amber base sits closest to the bottom of Bayside Cedar, and the green top keeps the rainy feel.

"What is that crackling sound?"

That is the wooden wick. Wood crackles softly as the flame draws melted wax up through the grain. The flat wood wick also spreads the flame wider, which helps the pool melt evenly.

How to get the full scent out of your beeswax candle

A few habits make the difference between a candle that tunnels and one that burns clean to the bottom.

  • Let the first burn reach the edges. Wax has a memory. If the first pool stops short of the jar, later burns tend to follow that smaller ring, so give the first burn two to three hours.
  • Trim the wooden wick before each burn. Keep it about an eighth of an inch. A long wood wick throws a tall flame and can smoke.
  • Cap each burn at about four hours. Longer burns let the flame grow taller than it needs to be.
  • Keep fresh air moving, away from drafts. A draft bends the flame and melts the pool unevenly. The EPA's guide to indoor air quality at home covers simple ways to keep a room well aired.

Frequently asked questions

What does Yankee Candle Bayside Cedar actually smell like?

Like a path through the woods after rain. It opens with bergamot, green pear and grapefruit, softens into mandarin blossom and water lily, then dries down to amber, cedarwood and musk. Our Do Not Disturb beeswax candle shares its pear and bergamot top and its amber base.

Is there a candle that smells exactly like Bayside Cedar?

Exact clones are rare, since every house blends its own oils. The closest match copies both the fruit top and the warm wood base. That is why Do Not Disturb ranks first, and why Touch Grass ranks second for readers who want more cedar.

I like the coastal side of Bayside Cedar more than the wood. What should I light?

Look at our Zesty beeswax candle. Its notes are Ocean Breeze, Mandarin, Lavender, Jasmine, Black Pepper, Amber, Patchouli, Vanilla, so you get a salt-air and mandarin opening with amber underneath.

How long do beeswax candles actually burn?

Beeswax has the highest melting point of any candle wax, so it burns slowly. Every scent in our beeswax candle collection comes in a 5 oz size that burns 40 hours and a 12 oz size that burns 80+ hours.

Our pick: Do Not Disturb in the 12 oz size

Bayside Cedar works because bright fruit sits on top of warm wood. The closest way to get that on clean-burning beeswax is a candle that copies both layers, and Do Not Disturb does it best.

Light it in the bedroom and the room smells like pear and Earl Grey at dusk, then settles into amber and sandalwood as you turn in. The specs back that feeling up. Its pear and bergamot top and amber base line up with Bayside Cedar, and two wooden wicks carry the scent for 80+ hours on 100% beeswax with phthalate-free fragrance.

"I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good"

Verified buyer

If your Bayside Cedar jar is already down to the last inch, order now so the new candle is on your nightstand before the old one goes out.

Get Do Not Disturb in the 12 oz, 80-hour size, because it matches the scent you already love in the room you light every night.

Related reading

Best Candles That Smell Like Yankee Candle Bayside Cedar: 5 Picks Ranked by How Close They Get
Previous Article Best Candles That Smell Like Mainstays Warm App...
Next Article The 5 Best Candles That Smell Like WoodWick Eve...
Back to MBur blog