WoodWick has discontinued Island Coconut in most of its sizes. Much of what still shows up online is leftover stock sold by resellers. If your reorder keeps landing on an out-of-stock page, that is the reason, and it will not change.
The obvious fix is to track down one more jar on a resale site and stretch it as long as you can. That buys you a few weeks with a candle of unknown age, and then you are back where you started. The lasting fix is to break Island Coconut into its parts, the scent and the sound, and find a candle that carries both. A few of our hand-poured beeswax candles with wooden wicks fit that job, and one comes closer than anything else we have found.
What Island Coconut really smelled like
WoodWick built Island Coconut around two notes: juicy crushed pineapple and creamy coconut. Its descriptions also mention hints of banana and vanilla underneath. The pineapple is the bright top you notice first. The coconut and vanilla sit lower and give the scent its soft, creamy finish.
That pairing is rarer than it sounds. Most coconut candles lean hard one way. Some go full beach, with salt air and sunscreen. Others go full dessert, all sugar and cream.
Island Coconut sat between those two. The sharp pineapple kept the coconut from turning heavy and sweet. So the first test for any replacement is simple: does it pair coconut with a bright, juicy fruit? A coconut candle without that fruit will smell like a different candle.
The second test has nothing to do with smell.
The sound that made up the other half of the candle
WoodWick built its whole name on the crackle. For a lot of its fans, that soft popping was half of why they bought the candle. Lose it, and even a perfect scent match feels off.
Here is why that sound happens. A wooden wick is a thin strip of wood. As the flame draws melted wax up through the grain, tiny pockets of air and moisture in the wood heat up and pop. That small, steady pop is the crackle you remember.
A cotton wick has no wood grain, so it burns quietly. That rules out a large share of coconut candles before you smell a single one. It also leaves one question most shoppers skip: what is the wax under that wick made of?
Why one more secondhand jar rarely fixes it
Before the wax question, it helps to look hard at the resale route. A discontinued candle on a resale site has no pour date on it. You cannot tell if it spent two summers in a warm garage or a hot delivery truck.
Both of those matter. Fragrance oil in a candle can lose strength as it ages, and heat speeds that up. Wax that softened and set again can also burn unevenly. So the jar that arrives may smell fainter than the one you remember, and it may tunnel down the middle.
Even a perfect jar only delays the problem. When it runs out, the search starts over. A candle you can reorder from the maker, freshly poured, ends the search for good.
The wax decides how long the scent lasts
Every candle burns its wax as fuel. The flame melts the wax, the wick draws it up, and the heat turns it into vapor that burns. The scent rides along with that melted wax into the room.
Now add one fact. A wax with a higher melting point melts more slowly, so the same jar holds more hours of burn. Beeswax has the highest melting point of any common candle wax. That is why a 12 oz beeswax candle can burn for 80 hours or more.
Beeswax is also a single ingredient. Bees make it, and beekeepers collect it as a byproduct of honey. Nothing gets blended in to stretch it. That gives a candle a steady flame and a clean, even melt pool.
Put the tests together and the field gets small fast. You want coconut paired with a bright fruit. You want a wooden wick for the crackle. And you want a slow-burning wax so one jar lasts through a season of evenings. Picture the first night in a beach rental, windows open, someone slicing a cold pineapple at the counter. One candle in our line was built around that exact moment, and it opens the list below.
The best candles that smell like WoodWick Island Coconut, ranked
We ranked these by how closely each one matches what Island Coconut fans miss most: pineapple with coconut, plus the crackle. The closest match comes first.
1. MBur Out of Office: the closest match to Island Coconut
Our Out of Office pineapple and coconut beeswax candle lists both of the notes that defined Island Coconut. The full notes are Spearmint, Pineapple, Bamboo, Coconut. Light it and the pineapple comes first, juicy and sweet-tart, greener and sharper than the canned kind.
Over that sits a cool line of spearmint, like a fresh leaf crushed between your fingers. Underneath is the green, watery smell of fresh-cut bamboo. Coconut rounds out the base, soft and creamy. Where Island Coconut used banana and vanilla, Out of Office uses spearmint and bamboo, so it reads a little fresher and brighter.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: Wooden (two on the 12 oz) | Fragrance: Phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: None
Standout feature: It is the only pick here that pairs pineapple and coconut with a crackling wooden wick and a slow-burning wax.
Best for: the living room where you burned Island Coconut most nights.
Size and price: Get the 12 oz, 80-hour size ($65) for that room. Two wooden wicks melt a wider pool of wax, and a wider pool sends more scent across a bigger space.
"They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out. I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good"
Paige, verified buyer who owns six of the scents
That point about scent lingering after the flame is out matters for a coconut fan. The creamy base notes are the ones that hang in the air. In Out of Office, that job falls to the coconut.
2. MBur Touch Grass: for the softer, creamier side of coconut
Some Island Coconut fans loved the warm base more than the fruit. Think of a patio door left open after rain, the air green and cool, with something soft and sweet underneath it. That is where Touch Grass, our green coconut and fig beeswax candle lives.
Its notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean. Galbanum is a green plant resin with a bitter, fresh snap. Fig and black currant bring dark, tangy fruit. Coconut, amber, and tonka bean give it the warm, creamy floor that vanilla gave Island Coconut.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: Wooden (two on the 12 oz) | Fragrance: Phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: None
Standout feature: Coconut wrapped in green, garden notes with a warm tonka bean and amber base.
Best for: a reading corner by the patio door, a sunroom, or a guest room.
Size and price: The 5 oz, 40-hour size ($32) suits these rooms. One wooden wick fills a small space, and a room you use a few nights a month does not need two.
3. WoodWick Island Getaway Trilogy
This one keeps Island Coconut alive in a different form. The Trilogy layers three scents in one jar: Coastal Sunset, Seaside Mimosa, and Island Coconut. WoodWick still sells it, and it carries the brand's well-known crackle.
The catch is in the layers. Each scent sits in its own band of wax, so Island Coconut gets one stretch of the burn and shares the rest with two other scents. If you want the pineapple and coconut every night, Out of Office gives you that from the first burn to the last.
4. Yankee Candle Coconut Beach
Yankee Candle is the household name in scented candles, and Coconut Beach is one of its long-running tropical scents. Reviewers know it for a strong, sunny, beach-day coconut. Yankee Candle and WoodWick now sit under the same parent company, Newell Brands.
Coconut Beach goes for the beach side of coconut, the salt-air and suntan feel. Island Coconut fans who loved the juicy pineapple will find more of it in Out of Office.
5. Chesapeake Bay Candle Sea Salt Coconut
Chesapeake Bay Candle has a calm, coastal house style, and its jars are a common sight in home stores. Sea Salt Coconut pairs coconut with a salty, ocean-air side. It shows up often when people search for Island Coconut alternatives.
The sea salt pulls it toward the shoreline and away from the fruit stand. For the pineapple-and-coconut pairing you are trying to get back, Out of Office is the closer match.
The picks side by side
| Pick | How the coconut reads | House style |
|---|---|---|
| 1. MBur Out of Office | Juicy pineapple over creamy coconut, cooled by spearmint | 100% beeswax, wooden wick, phthalate-free fragrance, 80+ hours on the 12 oz |
| 2. MBur Touch Grass | Soft coconut under green fig and galbanum, warm tonka base | 100% beeswax, wooden wick, phthalate-free fragrance, 80+ hours on the 12 oz |
| 3. WoodWick Island Getaway Trilogy | Island Coconut as one of three layered scents | Known for its crackle |
| 4. Yankee Candle Coconut Beach | Beach-day coconut | Classic household tropical scent |
| 5. Chesapeake Bay Candle Sea Salt Coconut | Coconut with a salty ocean side | Calm, coastal home style |
Our pick: Out of Office for the room you miss it in most
If you want Island Coconut back, start with Out of Office. It is the one candle on this list that pairs pineapple with coconut every hour of the burn. Its wooden wick brings back the crackle, and its beeswax burns slowly enough to last through a long run of evenings.
Touch Grass is the second pick, and it is the right one for a smaller room or for anyone who loved the creamy base more than the fruit. Between the two, you have both sides of Island Coconut covered.
What fans of the original usually ask next
"But Island Coconut had a loud crackle."
Both MBur picks use wooden wicks, and the 12 oz size has two of them. Two wicks mean two flames drawing wax through the wood grain, so you get more of that soft popping across the jar. For a big living room, the 12 oz Out of Office gives you the fullest version of the sound.
"But my old jar lasted for weeks."
Then match the jar to the habit. If you lit Island Coconut most nights, the 80-hour size is the one for you. Beeswax melts slowly, so those hours hold up from the first burn to the last.
"But I loved the vanilla in it."
That is a sign to look at Touch Grass. Its tonka bean and amber give the same warm, rounded finish that vanilla gave Island Coconut. Put it in the room where you wind down, and keep Out of Office for the room where you want the bright fruit.
FAQ
Is WoodWick Island Coconut actually discontinued?
Yes, in most formats. A HearthWick version is still listed by the maker, but most retailers show Island Coconut as out of stock, and much of what remains sells on resale sites. If you want a coconut candle you can keep reordering, browse our beeswax candle collection.
Do MBur candles crackle like a WoodWick?
They do, because every MBur candle uses a wooden wick. The crackle comes from small pockets of air and moisture in the wood popping as they heat. You hear it most in the 12 oz Out of Office beeswax candle, which has two wicks.
Which candle smells most like Island Coconut?
Out of Office is the closest. Its notes are Spearmint, Pineapple, Bamboo, Coconut, so it keeps the pineapple and coconut at the center. Read the full scent story on the Out of Office product page.
What size should I get for a small bedroom or bathroom?
The 5 oz, 40-hour size. A single wooden wick fills a small room well, and it fits on a nightstand or the back of a tub. Touch Grass in the 5 oz size is a good fit for a room like that.
How do I get every hour out of a beeswax candle?
Let the first burn run until the melted wax reaches the edge of the jar. That sets an even melt line for every burn after it. Trim the wooden wick short before you light it each time, and every candle in our wooden wick beeswax collection will burn evenly to the bottom.
Bring the pineapple and coconut back
Island Coconut worked because it paired juicy pineapple with creamy coconut and set both over a crackling wick. Out of Office keeps that pairing, adds cool spearmint and fresh bamboo, and pours it in 100% beeswax with wooden wicks. It gives you back the evening you used to light Island Coconut for, with the sound and the scent in the same jar.
The burn hours hold up, too. One verified buyer wrote that her candle "burned slowly and was exactly the amount of hours the company said it would burn." That matters when you are choosing the size for the room you light most.
If your last jar of Island Coconut is near the bottom, order now so the new candle arrives before the old one runs out.