If your jar of Village Candle Forbidden Forest is down to the last inch and the shelf you bought it from keeps showing it out of stock, you can still get that smell back. Two of the five candles below match its cedar and eucalyptus closely, and both are poured in 100% beeswax with wooden wicks.
The best match is MBur Sunday Reset. It shares the original's cold eucalyptus opening and its cedar and patchouli base, and clove adds the warm, dark edge that smoke gave Forbidden Forest. It is one of the pure beeswax candles we hand pour in New York City, and its 12 oz jar burns on two wooden wicks, much like the two-wick jar you are replacing.
Why Forbidden Forest is so hard to replace
Village Candle describes Forbidden Forest as “lush green, wet moss and a hint of smoky air.” The listed notes back that up. The top is fresh herbs, pine needle and eucalyptus. The middle is fresh berries, and the base is woody, with cedarwood, patchouli and smoke.
Finding it has become the hard part. The Large Apothecary jar is marked discontinued, and the 26 oz size has shown as unavailable with no restock date. The 14 oz tumbler still has a listing through Stonewall Kitchen, but it has been showing out of stock.
Some buyers also noticed a gap between the name and the jar. A few expected something dark and woody and found it sweeter, closer to “citrus sugar” with a “light crisp sweet scent.” So your target has two parts: the cold green top and cedar base, with a touch of sweetness in the middle to round it off.
Matching those notes is only half the job, though. The other half is what the scent is carried in, and that decides how long your forest lasts.
The wax underneath decides how the forest burns
Village Candle makes Forbidden Forest in Maine from food-grade paraffin. To see what that means, follow paraffin back to where it starts. It begins as crude oil, which refineries heat and split into fuels and lubricating oils.
Along the way, a waxy material separates out of the lubricating oil. Refiners strip it out, then bleach and deodorize it so it can go into a jar. Paraffin is petroleum waste, cleaned up enough to hold fragrance. Research has shown that burning paraffin releases benzene, toluene and formaldehyde.
Beeswax comes from a very different place. Honeybees make it to build their comb, and beekeepers collect the wax caps when they harvest honey. They melt and filter it, and that is the whole process. Our candles use beeswax as the only wax, with no blend.
Beeswax also has the highest melting point of any candle wax. A harder wax melts more slowly, so the same jar burns longer: 40 hours in the 5 oz size and 80+ hours in the 12 oz. The flame gives off a warm light, the closest of any candle wax to natural sunlight.
Fragrance is the last piece. Many candles use toxic fragrance that contains phthalates, chemicals added to help a scent cling and linger. MBur uses only phthalate-free fragrance and no chemical dye, so the forest you smell is the scent you chose and nothing else.
With the notes and the wax both in view, here is how the five picks rank.
The 5 best candles that smell like Village Candle Forbidden Forest
We ranked these by how closely each one tracks Forbidden Forest's green top and woody base, then by what the candle is made of. The first two are the only picks here poured in 100% beeswax.
1. MBur Sunday Reset: the closest match to the cold, green forest
Picture the first cold morning of fall on a wooded trail after a night of rain. The cedar bark has gone dark with water, and each breath feels sharp and clean in your nose. That cold, wet edge is what most people miss when their Forbidden Forest jar runs out.
Our Sunday Reset beeswax candle opens on that same cold note. Its scent notes are Peppermint, Clove, Cedar, Patchouli, Vanilla, Eucalyptus. Eucalyptus, cedar and patchouli all appear in Forbidden Forest too, which is why the two read so much alike.
Peppermint pushes the opening colder, like a lungful of winter air. Then clove and cedar warm the room, the cedar dry like fresh-cut wood. Vanilla sits underneath and does the job the berries did in the original, softening the edges so the scent stays easy to live with.
Standout feature: It carries the original's eucalyptus top and its cedar and patchouli base, on two wooden wicks in the large size.
Best for: A living room or open main room you light most evenings, and anyone who loved the cold, clean side of Forbidden Forest.
Size and price: The 12 oz, 80-hour size ($65), with two wooden wicks to carry the scent across a bigger room.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
2. MBur Touch Grass: the forest's sweeter, berry side
Some people loved Forbidden Forest for the sweetness reviewers kept noticing, the berry note that made a dark scent feel friendly. Think of a garden right after rain, with wet stems along the path and a ripe fig split open in the grass.
Our Touch Grass beeswax candle is built around that moment. Its scent notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean.
Galbanum is a plant resin with a bitter, sappy smell, close to a stem snapped in your fingers. It gives the opening the wet green that Forbidden Forest calls moss. Black currant fills the berry middle, and cedarwood with amber gives the base its weight.
Standout feature: A green opening, a berry middle and a cedar base, which follows the original's structure from top to bottom.
Best for: A bedroom or home office you light a few evenings a week, and anyone who liked the original's sweeter side.
Size and price: The 5 oz, 40-hour size ($32), with one wooden wick sized for a smaller room.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
A forest candle only works if it reaches the far side of the room. That is the most common complaint about lighter forest scents. One verified buyer, writing about another scent from the same beeswax line, put it this way:
“Theres nothing I hate more than a candle that can't fill the room and baby this is NOT that. This candle permeates every corner of the room.”
Verified buyer
Sunday Reset and Touch Grass are poured from that same 100% beeswax with the same wooden wicks. The slow, even burn keeps releasing fragrance for the full life of the jar, so the forest is still there on hour 70.
3. Goose Creek Harry Potter Deathly Hallows
Goose Creek sells this as part of its licensed Harry Potter line. Its listed notes are ancient cedar, forest pine, eucalyptus mist and forbidden moss, which lines up with Forbidden Forest on paper.
Style: A themed collectible built around the films.
Where it lands: It matches the name and several notes. Our top two carry the same cedar and eucalyptus in 100% beeswax, which is why they rank above it.
4. Otherland Forest Veil
Otherland is a modern, design-led candle brand. Forest Veil lists cedar, smoke and vetiver, so it shares the smoky, woody base of the original.
Style: Dark and woody, aimed at a moody room.
Where it lands: Its listed notes stop at the base. Without the cold eucalyptus top or the berry middle, it covers only the back half of Forbidden Forest.
5. Yankee Candle Balsam & Cedar
Yankee Candle is one of the best-known names in candles, and Balsam & Cedar is a long-running seasonal scent. Its notes are balsam, cedarwood and juniper berry.
Style: A classic evergreen, built for the holidays.
Where it lands: Balsam leads, so it reads closer to a holiday tree than a damp forest floor. The juniper berry nods to the berry middle but sits lightly.
How the five compare on the forest notes
| Pick | Forest notes shared with Forbidden Forest | Style |
|---|---|---|
| 1. MBur Sunday Reset | Eucalyptus, cedar, patchouli | Cold green top, warm woody base, 100% beeswax |
| 2. MBur Touch Grass | Green top, berry middle, cedarwood | Sweet and green over wood, 100% beeswax |
| 3. Goose Creek Deathly Hallows | Cedar, pine, eucalyptus, moss | Film-themed collectible |
| 4. Otherland Forest Veil | Cedar, smoke | Dark and woody |
| 5. Yankee Candle Balsam & Cedar | Cedarwood, berry | Holiday evergreen |
Read across the rows and the pattern is clear. Our top two cover both halves of Forbidden Forest, the green top and the wood underneath, in the cleanest wax on the list.
Two reasons you might hesitate, and the size that settles each
“But the original filled my whole living room.”
Village Candle built its name on a two-wick jar, and that second wick is a real reason the scent travels. Two flames melt a wide pool of wax faster, and more melted surface means more fragrance in the air.
The 12 oz Sunday Reset uses the same idea with two wooden wicks. It is sized for the room where you spend most evenings, and its 80+ hours mean you are lighting the same jar through most of a season.
“But I liked that it was a little sweet.”
Then Touch Grass is your scent. The black currant and fig give it the soft, fruity middle that reviewers noticed in the original, with cedarwood keeping it grounded.
If you want that sweeter forest in a large living room, Touch Grass also comes in the 12 oz size with two wooden wicks. The room decides the size, and the scent stays the same.
Where a forest candle earns its place in your home
A forest scent does its best work in the colder months, in the room where you settle in after dark. Set Sunday Reset on a wood tray near a window in the living room. The cool glass and the warm flame together make the room feel like a cabin at the edge of the trees.
Touch Grass fits a bedroom shelf or a desk in a home office, where a 5 oz jar fills the space without crowding it. Blow it out before you sleep and the scent stays in the room for a while after.
A few habits keep either candle burning evenly to the bottom of the jar:
- On the first burn, let the melted wax reach the edge of the jar before you put it out. This sets the pattern for every burn after.
- Trim the wooden wick to about an eighth of an inch and brush off the char before each light.
- Burn for up to four hours at a time, then let it cool.
- Keep it out of drafts, which pull the flame sideways and melt one side faster. Crack a window in another part of the room for fresh air.
Questions forest-candle fans ask next
Is Village Candle Forbidden Forest discontinued?
Some sizes appear to be. The Large Apothecary jar is marked discontinued, the 26 oz size has shown as unavailable with no restock date, and the 14 oz tumbler has been out of stock at Stonewall Kitchen. If you want a forest scent you can reorder anytime, our beeswax candle collection keeps every scent in both sizes.
What does Forbidden Forest actually smell like?
The listed notes are fresh herbs, pine needle and eucalyptus up top, fresh berries in the middle, and cedarwood, patchouli and smoke at the base. In practice, many buyers found it sweeter than the name suggests. If that sweetness is what you miss, the Touch Grass beeswax candle keeps a berry middle over cedarwood.
Is there an MBur candle with more of the herb side of the forest?
Yes. The Wine Down beeswax candle has the notes Lavender, Chamomile, Sage, Rosemary, Camphor, Cedar, Sandalwood. The sage and rosemary bring the fresh-herb note from Forbidden Forest's top, and the cedar holds the base. It suits an evening bath or the last hour before bed.
How long does a beeswax forest candle actually burn?
Ours burn 40 hours in the 5 oz size and 80+ hours in the 12 oz. Beeswax has the highest melting point of any candle wax, so it melts slowly and lasts longer in the same jar. The Sunday Reset beeswax candle in the 12 oz size is the one to choose if you light it most nights.
Our pick: Sunday Reset in the 80-hour size
Forbidden Forest worked because it paired a cold, green top with a woody base. Sunday Reset carries the same eucalyptus, cedar and patchouli, in 100% beeswax with phthalate-free fragrance and no dye.
Choose the 12 oz size for your living room. It makes the room feel like the first cold walk of fall, and its two wooden wicks spread the scent the way your old two-wick jar did. The burn hours hold up, too. As one verified buyer wrote, the “Candle burned slowly and was exactly the amount of hours the company said it would burn.”
If your last jar of Forbidden Forest is close to empty, now is the time to settle on its replacement, before the cold months when a forest scent is the candle you reach for most.
Bring the forest back with the 80-hour Sunday Reset for your living room, because it is the candle you will light every evening once the weather turns.