Home / MBur blog

Best Candles That Smell Like Tyler Candle Company Icon: The Closest Notes in Pure Beeswax

Best Candles That Smell Like Tyler Candle Company Icon: The Closest Notes in Pure Beeswax

If you searched for the best candles that smell like Tyler Candle Company Icon, you want that powdery iris and warm sandalwood scent, and you may want it without the soy and paraffin blend Icon is poured in. You can get very close by matching Icon note by note, and the closest matches come in pure beeswax.

What customers say on Google
View on Google

A common myth says a real Icon alternative has to be a copycat "dupe." Tyler's fragrances are proprietary, so no brand can reproduce one exactly, and most dupes smell close in the jar and wrong once lit. The closest match in our hand poured beeswax candle collection is Touch Grass, because it shares Icon's iris and its warm amber base, poured in 100% beeswax with wooden wicks and phthalate-free fragrance.

What Tyler Icon actually smells like, and which notes you need to match

Tyler lists Icon's notes as sandalwood, ambergris, violet leaves, French verbena, and Florentine iris. The company calls it spicy and sporty. In a room it reads fresh and clean, closer to a good cologne than to a sweet bakery candle.

Each of those notes does a specific job. Sandalwood is a soft, creamy wood that sits low and lasts. Ambergris is a warm, slightly salty note that smells like clean skin. Violet leaf is green and crisp, the smell of a crushed stem. Verbena is a lemony herb.

Florentine iris is the note most people remember. Perfumers get it from the root of the iris plant, dried for years and then distilled. That root material is called orris, and it smells dry, powdery, and a little like lipstick.

So a candle that smells like Icon has to cover two things first: the powdery iris and the warm base under it. The green and lemony notes on top matter too, but they fade fastest. That points straight to the next question, which is where you find orris in a clean candle.

Start with the iris, the note that makes Icon recognizable

Think about the clean, dry smell inside a leather handbag that once held a bottle of perfume. Or the soft powder on a freshly pressed shirt. That faint, almost velvet smell is iris, and it is why Icon smells polished instead of sweet.

Our Touch Grass pure beeswax candle carries that same root as orris. Its notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean. Here is how those line up with Icon.

  • Orris is the iris itself. It is the same family of material behind Icon's Florentine iris.
  • Galbanum is a resin from a plant in the fennel family. It smells sharply green, like snapping a fresh stem, which fills the space violet leaf fills in Icon.
  • Amber and tonka bean build the warm base. They sit where Icon's ambergris sits, low and steady under everything else.
  • Cedarwood gives the dry wood backbone that sandalwood gives Icon.

Touch Grass opens a little greener and fruitier than Icon, because fig and black currant lead. As the melt pool deepens, those top notes settle and the orris, amber, and cedar carry the room. If you love Icon for its powder and its warmth, this is your candle.

If sandalwood and verbena are what you love, look here

Some Icon fans care less about the powder and more about the fresh, lemony wood. Rub a lemon verbena leaf between your fingers and you get lemon peel with an herbal edge behind it. Put that over a creamy wood and you have the side of Icon that reads sporty.

For that reader, our Just to Clarify beeswax candle with sandalwood and green tea is the match. Its notes are Bergamot, Lemon, Orange, Green tea, Black tea, Sandal wood.

Bergamot and lemon cover verbena's bright citrus lift. Green tea adds a crisp leafy edge that sits close to violet leaf. Sandalwood is the same backbone note Icon is built on, so the drydown feels familiar.

Just to Clarify is lighter and brighter than Touch Grass. It suits a bedroom, a reading corner, or a desk where you want calm and clean. Both candles answer the same question from different sides. The next thing to settle is why the same notes smell different in beeswax than in a soy and paraffin blend.

Why the same notes smell different in a different wax

A candle holds its fragrance oil inside the wax. When you light it, the flame melts a pool around the wick. Heat then lifts fragrance off the surface of that pool and into the room.

The wax sets how that pool behaves. A wax with a higher melting point melts more slowly, so the candle burns longer and releases scent at a steady pace. Beeswax has the highest melting point of the common candle waxes, which is why our 12 oz size burns 80+ hours.

The wax also decides what else goes into the air. To see why that matters, it helps to walk through where each wax comes from, one step at a time.

Where paraffin comes from

Crude oil goes to a refinery, where it is heated and split into parts. The lighter parts become fuels. The heavier parts become lubricating oils.

As those lubricating oils are cleaned, a waxy solid separates out. That solid is paraffin. It is what remains after the valuable products are taken, so paraffin is petroleum waste.

Where soy and blends fit

Soy wax starts as soybean oil, which is processed so it turns solid at room temperature. It is soft, so many makers blend it with paraffin to firm it up and hold more fragrance. Tyler describes its candles as a blend of soy and paraffin.

Where beeswax comes from

Worker bees make beeswax from glands on their bodies and use it to build the comb. After the honey harvest, beekeepers melt and filter the comb wax. Nothing else needs to be added to make it burn, so a 100% beeswax candle is a single-ingredient wax.

People have burned beeswax since about 5,000 BCE. It also gives off a warm light close to natural sunlight, which is why a beeswax candle looks golden in the jar and on the wall.

Tyler Icon and MBur beeswax, side by side

Tyler Icon MBur beeswax (Touch Grass, Just to Clarify)
Wax Soy and paraffin blend 100% beeswax, a single-ingredient wax
Wick Two wicks on the 22 oz jar Wooden wick; two wooden wicks on the 12 oz size
Burn behavior Soft plant wax mixed with a petroleum wax Highest melting point of common candle waxes; 80+ hours on the 12 oz, 40 hours on the 5 oz
Soot Paraffin in the blend can leave black soot on jars and walls No paraffin, so no paraffin soot
Fragrance Sandalwood, ambergris, violet leaves, French verbena, Florentine iris Phthalate-free; Touch Grass shares the iris (orris) and amber, Just to Clarify shares the sandalwood
Dye Colored to the house style No chemical dye; the color is the beeswax itself
Where it is made Handcrafted in the USA Hand poured in New York City

The table settles the notes and the wax. The question most Icon fans ask next is whether a beeswax candle can fill a room the way Icon does.

Does beeswax fill a room as well as Icon?

Candle makers talk about two kinds of scent. Cold throw is what you smell from the unlit jar. Hot throw is what fills the room once the melt pool forms.

Hot throw depends on how wide and even the melt pool gets. On our 12 oz size, two wooden wicks melt the surface edge to edge faster than one wick could. That wide pool gives the fragrance more surface to lift from, which is what you want in a living room or an open kitchen.

Base notes also matter after you blow it out. Amber and tonka are heavy, slow-evaporating materials, so they hang in the air longer than bright citrus does. That is why Touch Grass keeps the room smelling warm after the flame is gone, the same lingering quality people love in Icon.

Our customers describe it the same way:

"They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out."
Paige, MBur customer

For a large room, that is the case for the 12 oz Touch Grass with its two wooden wicks. Strong scent is half of what makes Icon worth matching. The other half is what you breathe while it burns.

What goes into your air while it burns

If you have wondered whether your candle affects the air in your home, that is a fair question. Research has found that paraffin candles release benzene, toluene, and formaldehyde as they burn. These are volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, which means chemicals that turn into gas and mix into indoor air.

The risk comes from specific ingredients, so you can shop around it. Here is what to watch for on any label.

  • Paraffin, alone or in a blend. It is the source of the black soot that builds up on jar rims and walls.
  • Toxic fragrance. Many candles use toxic fragrances that can contain phthalates and parabens. Phthalates are chemicals often used to make scent last longer.
  • Metal-core wicks. Some wicks have a metal center to keep them standing upright.
  • Chemical dyes. Added color is one more ingredient burning into the air.

MBur checks every box on that list. Our candles are 100% beeswax with wooden wicks, non-toxic phthalate-free fragrance, and no chemical dye. You keep the Icon-style scent you came for and drop the ingredients you were trying to avoid.

A few habits help any candle burn cleaner. Let the first burn run until the melt pool reaches the edge of the jar, which usually takes two to three hours. Trim the wooden wick short and wipe away the charred tip before each light. Keep each burn to about four hours, and crack a window in a small room.

The winner for each room in your home

These picks are ranked by how many of Icon's notes each candle shares, best first. Your room and your routine decide the scent and the size.

Best overall Icon match: Touch Grass, 12 oz

Touch Grass shares the iris and the warm base, the two notes that make Icon recognizable. Choose the 12 oz size for a living room or any room you light most nights. Two wooden wicks and 80+ hours of burn mean it fills the space and keeps going all season.

Best for the fresh, sandalwood side of Icon: Just to Clarify

If you reach for Icon because it smells clean and sporty, Just to Clarify fits better. Sandalwood under bergamot and green tea gives you that crisp, lemony wood. It works well in a bedroom, an office, or a yoga corner.

Best for a small room or occasional use: either scent in 5 oz

A bathroom, a guest room, or a desk you sit at twice a week does not need two wicks. The 5 oz size has one wooden wick and burns 40 hours. Pick the scent by note: Touch Grass for powder and warmth, Just to Clarify for fresh wood.

But what about...

"But Icon is the scent I already know my house by."

That loyalty makes sense, since a scent becomes part of how a home feels. Touch Grass keeps the parts you know, the powdery iris and the warm drydown. Start it in the room where you burned Icon most, and pick the 12 oz size so the scent carries the same distance.

"But Touch Grass has fig and coconut, and Icon does not."

Those notes sit at the top and the middle of the blend, so they show most in the first part of the burn. The orris, amber, and cedarwood take over as the room warms. If you want less fruit from the very first minute, Just to Clarify is the one for you.

"But I have never burned a beeswax candle."

Beeswax burns much like any jar candle, with two small differences you will notice. The wooden wick crackles softly as it burns. The first burn matters most, so give it the full two to three hours to melt edge to edge, and every burn after will stay even.

Frequently asked questions

What candle smells most like Tyler Icon?

The closest match by notes is our Touch Grass beeswax candle. It shares Icon's iris as orris and its warm amber base, with cedarwood standing in for the dry wood.

What are the notes in Tyler Icon, and which MBur candle has sandalwood?

Icon's notes are sandalwood, ambergris, violet leaves, French verbena, and Florentine iris. If sandalwood is the note you love most, our Just to Clarify candle with sandalwood and bergamot builds on that same wood.

I wear a fresh cologne. Is there a sportier option?

Yes. Our Zesty beeswax candle has the notes Ocean Breeze, Mandarin, Lavender, Jasmine, Black Pepper, Amber, Patchouli, Vanilla. The black pepper gives it spice and the ocean breeze reads like clean skin after a shower, close to the sporty side of Icon.

How long do beeswax candles actually burn?

Our 12 oz size burns 80+ hours on two wooden wicks, and our 5 oz size burns 40 hours on one. Beeswax has the highest melting point of common candle waxes, so it melts slowly. Every scent in our pure beeswax candle collection comes in both sizes.

Why do dupe candles smell right in the jar but wrong when lit?

Many copycats chase the top notes and skip the base, so the jar smells close but the room smells thin once the flame lifts the heavier notes. Matching the base is what makes a match hold up. That is why Touch Grass keeps the amber and orris that sit under Icon.

The candle to light in Icon's place

No candle copies Tyler Icon exactly, and the best match comes from sharing its key notes. The iris and the warm base carry Icon, and Touch Grass carries both in 100% beeswax. You get the scent you came for in a wax with no paraffin and no toxic fragrance.

For the room you light most nights, choose the 12 oz Touch Grass ($65). It will make your living room smell the way it did with Icon, warm and polished when people walk in. The reason is in the jar: orris and amber over cedarwood, two wooden wicks for a wide melt pool, and 80+ hours of burn time.

One customer put the room-filling part plainly:

"Theres nothing I hate more than a candle that can't fill the room and baby this is NOT that. This candle permeates every corner of the room."
Tiffany Gordon, MBur customer

With windows shut for the colder months, a room holds a warm amber scent longest, so this is the season it does its best work.

Choose the 12 oz Touch Grass for the room you light most, because it carries Icon's iris and amber through every evening in that room.

Related reading

Best Candles That Smell Like Tyler Candle Company Icon: The Closest Notes in Pure Beeswax
Previous Article Best Candles That Smell Like Rituals Suede Vani...
Next Article Best Candles That Smell Like Rituals Sweet Oran...
Back to MBur blog