Home / MBur blog

Best Candles That Smell Like Swan Creek Candle Co. Honey Soaked Apples, Crisp and Sweet With No Spice

Swan Creek Candle Co. built Honey Soaked Apples around crisp fruit and a mild honey sweetness. It leaves out the heavy baking spice that most apple candles lean on, and that missing spice is the reason the scent is so hard to replace. Search for an apple candle and most of what comes back smells like a pie cooling on the counter, warm and brown and heavy with cinnamon.

What customers say on Google
View on Google

The usual fix is to keep searching for another honey apple candle and hope the next one lands. It tends to miss in one of two ways. Either the spice creeps back in, or the honey gets pushed so hard that the jar smells candied, closer to cough syrup than to a hive. Those two complaints come up again and again in buyer reviews of honey apple candles, and they shaped how we sorted our own pure beeswax candles, hand poured in New York City, when we chose which ones belong on this list.

What you are really trying to replace

Start with the scent, because the name on the jar hides what matters. Honey Soaked Apples opens on a crisp apple body, the cold snap of fresh fruit straight from the crisper drawer. The honey sits underneath, mild and sweet. It rounds the edges of the apple without taking over the room.

Swan Creek pours the scent in 100% American soybean wax, and the brand is known for strong fragrance throw. Throw is how far a candle's scent travels from the jar into the room. A big throw is part of why the original feels generous, and it is usually the second thing people miss after the spice problem.

So the target comes down to a short checklist:

  • Crisp, fresh fruit up front, with no bakery spice.
  • A soft sweetness underneath that stays in the background.
  • Enough throw to fill the room you light it in.

Every common replacement breaks at least one of those. Looking at how each one breaks is what leads to the answer.

Why the obvious dupes keep missing the mark

The spice creeps back in

Most apple candles are written as baked apple. Cinnamon and clove read instantly as fall, so they get added to make the apple feel familiar. The trouble shows up once the wax melts.

Fresh fruit notes are light, and they lift off the melt pool early in a burn. Spice notes are heavier, and they hang in the air long after. An hour in, the crisp apple has faded and the clove is running the room, which is the moment a candle that started close turns into a pie.

The honey turns into candy

Honey is a tricky note to build. A small amount reads as warm and round. Push the dose up to make the candle obviously honey and it tips into something sticky and sharp, the cough syrup smell buyers keep describing.

The effect gets stronger in a small room with the door shut. Sweet notes build up in still air, so a candle that seemed balanced in the store can feel heavy by the second evening. The honey in Honey Soaked Apples works because it stays mild.

The jar cannot fill the room

The third miss has nothing to do with the fragrance. A candle releases scent from its melted pool, so a wider pool sends more scent into the room. When one wick sits in a wide jar, the flame often cannot melt the wax out to the glass.

The candle then burns a narrow tunnel down the middle. The pool stays small and the throw stays weak, while a good share of the wax never burns at all. Buyers bring up tunneling in single-wick jars almost as often as they bring up scent.

Put the three misses side by side and a pattern shows up. Each one comes from chasing the word apple on the label. The closer path is to chase the balance the original strikes, crisp fruit over soft sweetness, and then make sure the wick can carry it across the room.

The fruit that does the same job as a crisp apple

Take a pear out of the refrigerator door after a week in the cold. The skin is beaded with water, and the flesh cracks at the first bite near the stem. The sweetness arrives a beat after the crunch, cool and clean.

That bite is the closest thing in the orchard to a fresh apple. Pears and apples are cousins, both pome fruits with the same crisp, watery flesh. A pear note gives a candle the snap that makes Honey Soaked Apples feel fresh, and it does it with no pull toward pie.

This is why our Do Not Disturb pure beeswax candle sits at the top of this list. Pear leads, with bergamot beside it. Bergamot is a small citrus fruit grown along one coastline in southern Italy, too tart to eat, so growers press the rind for its oil. It adds a clean lift over the pear, the same job the crispness does in the original.

Underneath, vanilla and amber fill the role the honey plays. They stay low and warm, a soft base that rounds the fruit without turning syrupy.

To be plain about it, neither of our picks lists apple or honey as a note. What they share with the original is the shape of the scent. Pure beeswax also has a faint, warm smell of its own that many people describe as honey-like, because it comes from the same comb that holds the honey.

Our picks, ranked by how close they come to the original's balance

The list runs from the closest match in balance to the brightest, then moves to the honey apple candles you already know. Our two picks come first because they hit the checklist above and every line of their labels is printed for you to read.

1. Do Not Disturb: the closest match in balance

Standout: Crisp pear and bergamot on top, with vanilla and amber giving the soft sweetness that honey gives in the original.

Notes: Pear, Bergamot, Peach Blossom, Amber, Jasmine, Vanilla, Sandalwood

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none

Best for: A bedroom, where you light a candle at night and want the scent to settle into the room. Peach blossom and jasmine soften the fruit, and sandalwood keeps the finish dry so the sweetness never sticks.

Price: $65 for the 12 oz, 80-hour size with two wooden wicks, the size to choose for a bedroom you light most nights.

The worry with any sweet candle in a bedroom is that it becomes too much by the time you turn in. One verified buyer described the opposite:

“I love the scent of this candle. It is lovely not overpowering. It's soothing fragrance more than covers my bedroom and bathroom. It is aromatherapy at its best.” Verified buyer

That line about covering two rooms matters here. It answers the throw question and the cloying question in the same breath.

2. Adi: the brightest, juiciest take

Standout: A stack of citrus with peach and agave underneath, for anyone who loved the fresh, refreshing side of Honey Soaked Apples most.

Notes: Lemon, Orange, Grapefruit, Mandarin, Tangerine, Lime, Peach, Agave

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none

Best for: An everyday candle in a kitchen or a small home office, where you want the room to feel awake. Mandarin brightens the opening, sweet and juicy, and grapefruit keeps it cool where other citrus would turn sour. Agave and peach give the base a soft, nectar-like sweetness that sits right where the honey would.

Price: $32 for the 5 oz, 40-hour size with one wooden wick, the size for a small room or one you light a few times a week.

Adi tends to become the scent people keep on hand once they have it. As one verified buyer put it:

“Everything from this company is amazing so this candle matching that energy is no surprise. Will definitely be buying again.” Verified buyer

The honey apple candles shoppers compare them with

These three come up most often when people look for a Honey Soaked Apples match. Each has a following, and each is described here by its general style.

3. Swan Creek Candle Co. Honey Soaked Apples

The original, and the reference point for everything on this list. Swan Creek is a soy candle maker with a loyal regional following, and this scent shows up in several formats, from glass jars with wooden lids to larger pantry jars and Drizzle Melts wax tarts. Its fans praise the clean, crisp fruit and the strong throw.

If you came here because your favorite jar is gone or hard to find, our picks carry the same crisp-over-sweet shape in pure beeswax with wooden wicks.

4. Bath & Body Works Honeycrisp Apple

A mass-market take from one of the best-known names in home fragrance. Its listed notes are golden honeycrisp apple, fresh sugarcane and apple blossom, which keeps it out of baking spice territory. Shoppers who grew up on mall candles tend to know it on sight.

5. DW Home Apple Honey Butter

The richest of the group. It pairs orchard apple with a smooth honey butter sweetness, so it leans creamy where Honey Soaked Apples leans crisp. It is built to stay sweet without going sugary.

All three are built around the word apple. Our two picks are built around the balance, and their labels tell you exactly what is burning in your room. The label is where the next question starts.

What the label tells you before you strike a match

Scent is what you shop for, but the wax decides how that scent reaches you. Every burning candle releases fine particles into the air, and the EPA's overview of indoor particulate matter sources lists candles among them. What sets one candle apart from another is what goes into the jar.

Paraffin is the wax in many mass-market candles, and it starts as crude oil. Refineries pull out fuels first. A heavy, waxy fraction is left behind, and that leftover is cleaned up and sold as candle wax, which is why we call paraffin petroleum waste. Research has shown that burning paraffin candles releases benzene, toluene and formaldehyde.

Beeswax starts in the hive. Bees make it to build their comb, and beekeepers collect it as a byproduct of the honey harvest. It is a single ingredient with no chemical processing, and it has the highest melting point of the common candle waxes. A higher melting point means the wax melts more slowly, which is why our 12 oz size burns for 80+ hours.

The rest of the label is worth the same attention:

  • Fragrance: Many candles use toxic fragrances containing phthalates and parabens. MBur uses only non-toxic, phthalate-free fragrance oils.
  • Wick: Look for a wick with no metal core. MBur uses wooden wicks, which burn evenly and crackle softly as they go.
  • Dye: Dye only changes how the wax looks. MBur candles contain no chemical dye.

But I still want the word apple

But neither pick says apple on the label

That is fair, and worth weighing honestly. Think about what you liked once the original was lit. For most people it was how the room felt, fresh and a little sweet with nothing heavy in the air.

That feeling comes from crisp fruit over soft sweetness, and both picks are built on that balance. So the real choice is which version suits the room. Do Not Disturb belongs in the bedroom, where you want the scent calm. Adi belongs in the kitchen or at the desk, where you want it bright.

But the original fills my whole living room

Then the size is your answer. The 12 oz candle carries two wooden wicks, so the melt pool reaches the glass and the whole surface of the wax gives off scent. That is the size for a living room or any open space.

“They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out.” Verified buyer

Which size goes in which room

  • 12 oz, two wooden wicks, 80+ hours: a bedroom you light most nights, a living room, or any larger or open space.
  • 5 oz, one wooden wick, 40 hours: a small room, a bathroom, or a desk you light now and then.

Give the first burn enough time for the wax to melt all the way to the edge of the jar. Wax tends to follow the shape of its first pool, so a full first burn sets up an even melt for every burn after. Before each light, trim the wooden wick to about an eighth of an inch and brush off any char so the flame stays steady.

Questions people ask about honey apple candles

What does Swan Creek Honey Soaked Apples smell like?

Crisp, fresh apple with a mild honey sweetness underneath and no heavy baking spice. If you want that crisp-over-sweet feel in pure beeswax, browse our hand-poured beeswax candle collection and start with the fruit-led scents.

Which MBur candle comes closest to Honey Soaked Apples?

Do Not Disturb is the closest match in balance. Pear and bergamot give the crisp fruit, and vanilla with amber gives the soft sweetness.

I like my honey apple candles sweeter and deeper. Which scent fits?

Look at the Retail Therapy beeswax candle. Its notes are Red Currant, Black Currant, Jasmine, Peach, Black Tea, Amber, Anise, Tonka Bean. Ripe peach and dark berries give it a fuller, juicier sweetness, and one verified buyer wrote that it “permeates every corner of the room.”

How long do beeswax candles actually burn?

The 5 oz size burns for about 40 hours, and the 12 oz size burns for 80+ hours. Beeswax has the highest melting point of the common candle waxes, so it melts slowly. A full first burn helps you get every one of those hours, whether you light the bright Adi beeswax candle in the kitchen or Do Not Disturb in the bedroom.

Our pick: Do Not Disturb for the room you light every night

Honey Soaked Apples works because it keeps crisp fruit on top and a mild sweetness underneath, with no spice weighing it down. Most apple candles lose that balance to cinnamon or to candy. Do Not Disturb keeps it, with pear and bergamot over vanilla and amber.

Choose the 12 oz, 80-hour Do Not Disturb for your bedroom. It is the room where a candle should feel calm and clean at the end of the day, and two wooden wicks carry the scent to every corner without crowding the air. Buyers come back to it, and as one verified buyer wrote, “I love these scented candles. I will purchase more.”

The reason to choose it now is simple: the bedroom is where you light a candle most often, so it is the room where a scent that misses lets you down every single night.

Choose the 12 oz Do Not Disturb beeswax candle for your bedroom, because it is the one built for the candle you light at the end of every day.

Related reading

Best Candles That Smell Like Swan Creek Candle Co. Honey Soaked Apples, Crisp and Sweet With No Spice
Previous Article Best Candles That Smell Like Mrs. Meyer's Peony...
Next Article Best Candles That Smell Like Cire Trudon Joséph...
Back to MBur blog