If your Paddywax Pomegranate & Spruce has burned down to the last half inch and the store has moved on to new seasonal scents, you are trying to replace one specific contrast. Tart red fruit sits on top of cold evergreen, and a little vanilla and spice holds the two together.
The closest match on this list is Touch Grass, a 100% beeswax candle that sets tart black currant and a green, sappy note called galbanum against coconut and cedarwood. It ranks first because it rebuilds that sweet-against-green shape in a wax that burns slowly and fills a real room. Buyers raise room fill as the main complaint about candles in this scent family. Touch Grass is one of our 100% beeswax candles hand poured in New York City, and the four picks after it serve readers who lean harder toward the fruit or the tree.
What you are actually smelling in Pomegranate & Spruce
Paddywax built this fragrance in three layers. The top is ripe pomegranate, strawberry and coconut milk. The middle brings Valencia orange peel, eucalyptus leaves, cinnamon sticks and clove. The base settles into cedarwood, vanilla bean, blue spruce and pine branches.
Read that list again and the name starts to make sense. The fruit is loudest when you first light the candle. The evergreen comes up later, once the wax has been warm for a while. That order is why so many people describe it as fruity first and Christmas tree second.
It also explains why the scent is hard to replace. Most candles pick a side. A pine candle smells like a tree lot, and a pomegranate candle smells like a punch bowl. Pomegranate & Spruce keeps both in the room at the same time.
Paddywax has poured this fragrance into several vessels over the years, including its ruby red Relish jar and a run of holiday tins. The brand rotates seasonal scents in and out, so the version you remember may not be on the shelf when you go looking. That gap is why a list of true matches is useful, and it raises the next question: what does a match need to get right?
The two halves a match has to cover
A good substitute has to deliver the tart fruit and the green wood together. Miss the fruit and you get a plain pine candle. Miss the green and you get something sweet that never reminds you of a cold December afternoon.
The second test is strength in the room. Fragrance oil rises off liquid wax, so the wider and steadier the melt pool, the more scent moves into the air. A small pool keeps the scent close to the table, and the far side of the room smells like nothing.
So every pick below is judged on two things. First, how closely it maps to the fruit-over-evergreen shape. Second, how well it can carry that shape across a living room. That second test is where wax and wick start to matter, and it is the reason the top two spots go where they do.
The 5 best candles that smell like Paddywax Pomegranate & Spruce
Ranked by how closely each one rebuilds the tart fruit and cold green contrast, and how well it holds that scent across a full room.
1. Touch Grass by MBur: the closest fruit-and-green match
Picture the first cold Saturday in December. The tree is up, a bowl of fruit sits on the counter, and the air by the window smells green and a little sharp. That is the moment Pomegranate & Spruce was made for, and it is the moment our Touch Grass beeswax candle fills best.
The notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean. Black currant gives you the dark, tart fruit that sits where pomegranate sits in the original. Galbanum is a resin taken from a plant in the fennel family, and it smells like a green stem snapped between your fingers.
Further down, coconut lines up with the coconut milk at the top of the Paddywax candle, and cedarwood matches its base. Davana is an herb grown in southern India with a soft, almost boozy fruit smell that rounds out the currant. Tonka bean and amber do the job vanilla bean does in the original, giving the candle a warm finish under all that green.
Fig is the bridge between the two halves. Its skin smells green and its flesh smells sweet, so it ties the fruit to the wood the way strawberry ties pomegranate to spruce in the Paddywax version.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz size | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
Standout feature: tart fruit and green wood stay in balance from the first light to the last hour, so neither half drowns out the other.
Best for: the reader who loved the fruit-first opening of the original and wants it to reach every corner of a living room.
Size and price: the 12 oz size ($65), with two wooden wicks and 80+ hours of burn time, for the room you light most nights.
2. Sunday Reset by MBur: the spruce side, front and center
Some readers remember Pomegranate & Spruce mostly for the cold, piney breath that arrives once the candle has burned for an hour. If that is the part you miss, this is your pick.
The notes in our Sunday Reset beeswax candle are Peppermint, Clove, Cedar, Patchouli, Vanilla, Eucalyptus. Peppermint and eucalyptus open cold and clean, the way the hallway smells when you carry a fresh-cut tree through the front door. Eucalyptus and clove both sit in the middle of the Paddywax candle, so this pick shares more of its spice heart than anything else here.
As the cold fades, cedar comes up dry and woody, with vanilla settling under it. Patchouli adds an earthy weight that reads like the ground beneath the trees. You give up the red fruit and gain the clearest version of the evergreen half.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz size | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
Standout feature: it carries the cold eucalyptus and clove from the middle of the original, with cedar and vanilla underneath.
Best for: a bedroom or small home office where you want the tree side of the scent without the sweetness.
Size and price: the 5 oz size ($32), with one wooden wick and 40 hours of burn time, for a smaller room or one you light a few evenings a week.
Room fill is the test that sinks most candles in this category, so it helps to hear from someone who burns these every day. A verified buyer wrote this about another scent poured the same way, in the same beeswax:
“Theres nothing I hate more than a candle that can't fill the room and baby this is NOT that. This candle permeates every corner of the room.” (verified buyer)
Touch Grass and Sunday Reset share that pour, with wooden wicks set in pure beeswax. That pairing is what carries the scent past the coffee table and into the rest of the room.
3. Paddywax Pomegranate & Spruce: the original
This is the reference point every other pick is measured against. Paddywax is known for decorative vessels, and this fragrance has appeared in its ruby red Relish jar and in a series of holiday tins.
Standout feature: the full layered profile described above, from pomegranate and strawberry at the top down to blue spruce and pine.
Where it lands: the original, when you can find it. Since Paddywax rotates seasonal scents, the jar you remember depends on what the shelves carry that year.
4. Sand + Fog Pomegranate & Spruce
Sand + Fog is a home fragrance brand with a coastal-inspired house style. Its candles usually come in heavy glass jars sold through home and department stores. Its take on this pairing uses a matching name and follows the same fruit-and-wood idea.
Standout feature: a familiar name for the scent pairing, sold in many stores.
Where it lands: closest to the original by name, built in a mainstream glass-jar style.
5. DW Home Pomegranate & Spice
DW Home leans toward seasonal, spice-forward scents. Its Pomegranate & Spice keeps the red fruit and pushes it toward darker plum and smoky wood, with a pine note in the base.
Standout feature: a smokier, spicier read on the fruit-and-pine pairing.
Where it lands: further from the original than the picks above, since smoke takes the place of the cold, clean spruce.
All five side by side
| Pick | Scent leans toward | Style |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Touch Grass (MBur) | Tart black currant over green galbanum and cedarwood | 100% beeswax, wooden wick, hand poured in New York City |
| 2. Sunday Reset (MBur) | Cold peppermint and eucalyptus over clove, cedar and vanilla | 100% beeswax, wooden wick, hand poured in New York City |
| 3. Paddywax Pomegranate & Spruce | Pomegranate and strawberry over blue spruce and pine | Decorative seasonal vessels, rotates in and out |
| 4. Sand + Fog Pomegranate & Spruce | Fruit and wood under a matching name | Coastal-inspired, heavy glass jars |
| 5. DW Home Pomegranate & Spice | Red fruit pushed toward plum, smoke and pine | Seasonal, spice-forward |
The scent column tells you which half of the original each candle carries. The style column hints at the part that decides how far that scent travels, which comes down to what the candle is made of.
Why the top two carry the scent further
Start with the wax, which sets the floor for everything else. Beeswax is made by honeybees, and beekeepers collect it as a byproduct of honey. MBur candles use it as the only wax in the jar, with nothing blended in.
Beeswax has the highest melting point of any common candle wax. Here is why that matters for this scent. A wax that melts at a higher temperature gives up its liquid slowly, so the pool stays steady for hours and releases fragrance evenly. That slow melt is also why the 12 oz size burns for 80+ hours.
Next comes the wick, the part doing the most work you never think about. A wooden wick is a flat strip of wood, so its flame spreads sideways and warms a wider circle of wax. You also hear a soft crackle as it burns, which suits a cold evening with the tree lit.
The 12 oz size has two wooden wicks. Two flames reach the edge of the jar sooner, and a pool that covers the whole surface puts more scent into the room. That is the plain mechanism behind the room-fill quote above.
Then there is the fragrance itself. A phthalate is a chemical some fragrance makers add to make a scent cling longer, and many candles use toxic fragrances that contain them. MBur uses only phthalate-free fragrance, and no chemical dye, so the wax keeps the natural color it came out of the hive with.
One last detail shows up after dark. Beeswax burns with a light close to natural sunlight, warm and golden. On a December night, that glow next to a tart, green scent is most of what people loved about the original in the first place. With the materials settled, the real question becomes which scent and size suit your room.
Which pick fits your room
Start with the half of the original you miss most. If you remember the first ten minutes, when the fruit hit before anything else, go with Touch Grass. If you remember the hour after, when the room smelled like a tree had been carried in, go with Sunday Reset.
Then match the size to the room. A living room, an open kitchen or any space you light most nights calls for the 12 oz size with two wooden wicks. A bedroom, a bathroom or a room you use a few nights a week suits the 5 oz size with one.
Plenty of readers end up with both scents in the house. Touch Grass goes in the room where people gather, and Sunday Reset goes in the room where you wind down or work. That split covers both halves of Pomegranate & Spruce, one room at a time.
The questions readers still bring up
“But I want it to smell exactly like the Paddywax one.”
Only Paddywax uses the Paddywax formula, so every candle on this list is an interpretation. The useful question is which half of the original you care about more. Touch Grass matches the fruit-and-green opening, and Sunday Reset matches the cold evergreen heart. Choose by the moment you remember, and the candle will feel familiar from the first light.
“But my living room opens straight into the kitchen.”
Open rooms need a wide melt pool, which is exactly what two wooden wicks provide. Choose the 12 oz Touch Grass for that space. On the first burn, let it go until the melted wax reaches the edge of the jar, so every burn after that starts with a full pool.
“But I only burn candles from Thanksgiving to New Year.”
Both picks fit that window. Touch Grass also carries into spring, since its fig and galbanum read like a garden after rain once the tree comes down. If you light candles only a few evenings a week, the 5 oz size suits that pace.
Frequently asked questions
Does any MBur candle list pomegranate or spruce as a note?
Neither of our picks lists those two notes by name. Touch Grass gets its tart fruit from black currant and its green from galbanum, while Sunday Reset gets its cold evergreen from peppermint and eucalyptus. Both sit in our pure beeswax candle collection, so you can read every scent side by side.
I like the berry side more than the tree. Which one should I get?
Touch Grass, because it keeps some green under the fruit. If you want even more berry, our Retail Therapy beeswax candle carries Red Currant, Black Currant, Jasmine, Peach, Black Tea, Amber, Anise, Tonka Bean. It sits closer to the pomegranate opening than to the spruce.
Which one smells more like Christmas?
Sunday Reset, for the tree. If what you miss is the orange peel and baking spice in the middle of the original, our People Watching beeswax candle carries Lemon, Orange, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Clove, Nutmeg, Allspice, Ginger. It smells like a spiced cake cooling on the counter.
How long do these candles actually burn?
The 5 oz size burns 40 hours on one wooden wick, and the 12 oz size burns 80+ hours on two. Beeswax melts at a higher temperature than other candle waxes, so it gives up its wax slowly. Both sizes are available for Touch Grass in pure beeswax.
Why does a wooden wick crackle?
Wood holds tiny pockets of air and moisture, and they pop softly as the flame reaches them. Keep the wick trimmed short before each burn so the flame stays steady. You will hear that crackle in Sunday Reset with its wooden wick from the first light.
Our pick
Pomegranate & Spruce works because tart fruit and cold evergreen share the room. Touch Grass rebuilds that contrast most closely, and pure beeswax with wooden wicks carries it across the whole room.
Choose Touch Grass in the 12 oz size for your living room. It is the candle for the evenings when the tree is lit and people are coming over. Black currant and galbanum give you the fruit-against-green you have been missing, and two wooden wicks carry it for 80+ hours.
“They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out. I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good” (verified buyer)
This is the scent of the coldest weeks of the year, and ordering now puts it on the table for all of them.
Get Touch Grass in the 12 oz size for your living room, because that is the room where the fruit and the green have the space to fill every corner.