Home / MBur blog

Best Candles That Smell Like Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills: How to Get That Cedar Mountain Air at Home

Best Candles That Smell Like Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills: How to Get That Cedar Mountain Air at Home

The two candles that come closest to Brooklyn Candle Studio's Catskills share only two of its seven notes each. Both of them share cedar. Cedar is the note that holds a room after the brighter notes have burned off.

What customers say on Google
View on Google

That detail explains why the usual fix so often falls short. Most people chasing the Catskills smell search for a pine or forest candle and buy whichever label sounds closest. The room smells green early in the burn, then goes flat, and the cabin feeling never arrives. The reason lies in how a scent is built from the bottom up, and it is the same check we run when we choose the notes for our pure beeswax candles on wooden wicks.

Why a pine candle so often misses the Catskills smell

Every fragrance is built in layers. Perfumers call them top, middle, and base notes. Top notes are made of the lightest molecules, so they lift off first and fade first. Base notes are heavier, so they leave the wax slowly and carry the scent through the rest of the burn.

Catskills follows that design closely. Brooklyn Candle Studio lists fir balsam and cypress as its top notes. Pine, eucalyptus, and juniper sit in the middle. Cedar and sandalwood make up the base.

A candle built around one pine note puts nearly all of its weight at the top of that structure. You get a bright green hit when the wax first melts. Then the light molecules leave the air, and nothing heavy is left to hold the room together. That is how a pine candle can smell right in the store and thin by the end of the evening.

So the green notes are the part you notice first, and the wood is the part you remember. Which wood, and where it sits in the scent, is the next thing to look at.

The note doing the most work sits at the bottom

Cedar has a dry, clean smell, close to fresh-cut lumber or a newly sharpened pencil. Sandalwood is softer and creamier, and it rounds off cedar's sharper edges. Put the pair under a layer of fir and eucalyptus and you get the Catskills effect: cold air coming through a door into a room with a wood floor.

Because base notes leave the wax slowly, they are also what you notice when you walk back into a room after the flame is out. That lingering wood is the cabin part of the memory. Fans of Catskills often call it a fall and winter scent, and the cedar base is a big reason why. Dry wood under cold air is the smell of a cabin with the stove going.

Picture a January evening in an apartment where the windows have been shut since November. The radiator ticks away, and the air has gone warm and stale. What you want is the first breath at a trailhead. Our Sunday Reset beeswax candle with eucalyptus and cedar is the one we point people to for that room. The first breath off the melt pool is cold, and then the cedar comes up underneath it, dry and clean.

Match the cedar first, then match the room

Once you see the structure, the search gets simple. You are looking for two things in a note list. The first is cedar or sandalwood at the base. The second is a cold green note near the top.

A candle with both will feel like Catskills even when it shares only a few of its notes, because it copies the shape of the scent. Both of our picks pass that test. The table lines up the full note lists so you can check the overlap yourself.

Candle Full note list Notes shared with Catskills
Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills (the reference) Fir Balsam, Cypress, Pine, Eucalyptus, Juniper, Cedar, Sandalwood Reference scent
MBur Sunday Reset Peppermint, Clove, Cedar, Patchouli, Vanilla, Eucalyptus Eucalyptus, Cedar
MBur Wine Down Lavender, Chamomile, Sage, Rosemary, Camphor, Cedar, Sandalwood Cedar, Sandalwood

We ranked the picks by where the shared notes sit. Sunday Reset comes first because it matches both halves of the Catskills feel, the cold air and the dry wood. Wine Down comes second because it matches the full Catskills base and trades the forest top for sharp green herbs.

1. Sunday Reset: cold air on top, cedar underneath

Standout feature: It opens with peppermint and eucalyptus, which gives you the same cold first breath that Catskills gets from fir and eucalyptus. Then it settles into cedar.

Who it is for: The person who loves Catskills for its winter feel and wants it in the living room or home office, the rooms where she spends the most hours.

Notes: Peppermint, Clove, Cedar, Patchouli, Vanilla, Eucalyptus

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, two on the 12 oz size | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 80+ hours (12 oz), 40 hours (5 oz) | Dyes: none

The cold comes first, sharp enough that you feel it behind your eyes. Clove follows, dark and sweet, and then cedar arrives, dry like fresh-cut wood. Patchouli and vanilla sit lowest of all.

That low layer gives the wood more weight, so the room stays warm and woodsy after the mint fades. If you want the cabin part of Catskills to carry further across a room, this deeper base is what does it.

Size: For a living room or a desk you sit at every day, choose the 12 oz size at $65. Its two wooden wicks open a wider melt pool, and a wider pool releases more scent into a larger room. It burns 80+ hours, which carries it through a long run of winter evenings.

2. Wine Down: the full Catskills base, with herbs on top

Standout feature: It shares both of the Catskills base notes, cedar and sandalwood. The wood that lingers in the room is the same pairing.

Who it is for: The person who wants that woodsy base in the room where her day ends, such as a bathroom or a small bedroom.

Notes: Lavender, Chamomile, Sage, Rosemary, Camphor, Cedar, Sandalwood

Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, one on the 5 oz size | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none

Camphor and rosemary open sharp and green, closer to crushed leaves on a hiking trail than to a pine tree. Sage moves in underneath, dry and silvery. Lavender and chamomile soften the middle before cedar and sandalwood land, the same way they land in Catskills.

The result keeps the mountain wood and swaps the evergreen forest for an herb garden at the edge of it. It suits the hour after a long day, when you want the room to slow down with you.

"Absolutely obsessed with M Bur Candle Co my roommate and I own 6/8 of the scents! They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out. I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good"

Verified buyer, Wine Down

Size: For a bathroom or a small bedroom, choose Wine Down in the 40-hour size, the 5 oz jar at $32. One wooden wick is the right amount of flame for a small room, and the cedar and sandalwood base reaches every corner without crowding it.

What sits under the scent changes how the scent reads

The note list tells you what you will smell. The wax and the wick decide how cleanly it reaches you. Fragrance leaves a candle from the surface of the melt pool, so whatever that pool is made of goes into the air with it.

Start with how paraffin is made. Refineries heat crude oil and split it into fuels like gasoline and diesel. A heavy, waxy residue is left behind, and that residue is refined further and bleached into the white blocks sold as paraffin. Paraffin is petroleum waste, and it burns with the black soot you see on the rim of a paraffin jar.

Beeswax starts somewhere else entirely. Bees make it to build their comb, and beekeepers collect it as a byproduct of honey. It is a single ingredient with nothing blended in. It also has the highest melting point of any candle wax, so it melts slowly, and that slow melt is why our 12 oz jar burns 80+ hours.

Fragrance matters just as much. Many candles use toxic fragrances containing phthalates and parabens. Every MBur candle uses phthalate-free fragrance, and none of them use chemical dyes, so the wax keeps its natural honey color.

The wick finishes the picture. A wooden wick gives a soft crackle as it burns, close to the sound of a small wood stove. Under a cedar scent, that sound does a lot of the cabin work on its own. Beeswax also gives off a light close to natural sunlight, so the glow reads warm and golden. Every jar is hand poured in New York City.

Other names that come up in this search

Two more brands show up often when people look for a woodsy, city-made candle. Here is what each is known for, so you can place them next to our picks.

3. Nest New York

Nest is a New York fragrance house known for polished, perfume-style home scents. Its candles come in decorative glass vessels that many people keep on display after the wax is gone. Shoppers who reach for Nest tend to care about how the jar looks on a shelf as much as how it smells.

4. P.F. Candle Co.

P.F. Candle Co. is a Los Angeles brand with amber apothecary jars and plain, minimal labels. It has a loyal following among people who like earthy, outdoorsy scents. The look is simple and casual, which fits a relaxed room.

Whatever shelf you shop from, the test from earlier still applies: cedar or sandalwood at the base, and a cold green note on top. Sunday Reset and Wine Down pass it on a 100% beeswax pour with wooden wicks and phthalate-free fragrance. That combination is why they hold the top two spots.

The questions people raise before they switch

"My Catskills jar is almost empty, and I liked it."

Put Sunday Reset in the same spot. It covers the cold opening and the cedar base, the two parts you were really buying. The clove and vanilla underneath give it a little more depth, so the room holds the wood longer between burns.

"Catskills feels like a winter scent. What about the rest of the year?"

This comes down to which room and which season. Sunday Reset belongs to the closed-window months in the living room. Wine Down's herbs read fresh and green in spring and summer, and its cedar and sandalwood base keeps the Catskills thread running in the bathroom or bedroom all year.

"My living room is big and open."

Go with the 12 oz size. Two wooden wicks melt a wider pool than one, and the wider pool puts more scent into the air. Burn it long enough on the first night for the melted wax to reach the edge of the jar.

FAQ

What does Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills actually smell like?

Brooklyn Candle Studio lists Fir Balsam and Cypress on top, Pine, Eucalyptus, and Juniper in the middle, and Cedar and Sandalwood at the base. The overall effect is cold green forest over dry wood. You will find that same cedar base across several of our beeswax candles, and Sunday Reset is the closest match at both ends.

Do you have a candle that smells more like being outside?

Yes, Touch Grass. Its notes are Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean. Galbanum is a green plant resin with a bitter, sappy smell, and it gives Touch Grass, our garden-after-rain beeswax candle, its outdoor edge. It shares cedar with Catskills and leans toward a garden more than a forest.

Why does my wooden wick crackle, and is that normal?

It is normal. Melted wax travels up through the grain of the wood, and the soft pops come from the wick burning along that grain. Trim the wick a little before each burn to keep the flame steady, including on the two wooden wicks of our 12 oz Sunday Reset candle.

How do I keep a beeswax candle from tunneling down the middle?

On the first burn, keep the candle lit until the melted wax reaches the edge of the jar. The first melt pool sets the pattern for every burn after it. If the flame looks small, trim away any charred bits and clear the wax pooled around the wick, which helps the single wick on the 5 oz Wine Down burn wide and even.

Our pick: Sunday Reset, for the room you live in

The Catskills smell comes from its shape: a cold green top over a cedar and sandalwood base. Match that shape and the cabin feeling follows, even when the note lists only partly overlap. Both of our picks do it, and one does it at both ends.

Our pick is Sunday Reset in the 12 oz size. It brings the cold-air opening and the dry cedar base together, so the room you sit in every night feels like you just came in from a walk in the woods with the stove going. The reasons are all in the jar: eucalyptus and cedar shared with Catskills, two wooden wicks, and 80+ hours of 100% beeswax with phthalate-free fragrance and no dyes.

"Candle burned slowly and was exactly the amount of hours the company said it would burn."

Verified buyer

The weeks when the windows stay shut are when a closed room needs that cold, clean air most, so order it now and it will be on the table the next cold night.

Get the 80-hour Sunday Reset for your living room, because that is the room where the cedar has the hours to settle in.

Related reading

Best Candles That Smell Like Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills: How to Get That Cedar Mountain Air at Home
Previous Article Best Candles That Smell Like Archipelago Botani...
Next Article Best Candles That Smell Like Trapp Tuberose: Ho...
Back to MBur blog