If you want candles that smell like Boy Smells Rhubarb Smoke, both picks below carry a note straight off its list, fig in one and black tea in the other. Both also burn on wooden wicks in 100% beeswax. Our top pick is Touch Grass, because it sets tart green fruit over dry cedarwood, the same shape that makes Rhubarb Smoke so easy to love.
Rhubarb Smoke comes from the limited Hypernature line, and many retailers list it as out of stock. That leaves you hunting for the same sour green top and dark woody base in a candle you can reorder. The closest version sits among the pure beeswax candles we hand pour at MBur in New York City, and two of them earn a spot here.
Start with the notes you actually remember
Boy Smells lists nine notes for Rhubarb Smoke: incense, rhubarb, violet leaves, black tea, birch, smoked papyrus, ivy, wild figs and tanned leather. Few people pick out all nine once the candle is lit. What sticks is the overall shape of the scent.
Reviewers often say the rhubarb reads faintly and the smoke takes the lead as it burns. That makes sense once you look at the base. In perfumery, birch is a classic source of smoky leather, and smoked papyrus pushes in the same direction.
Rhubarb itself is a sour stalk. Its smell is green and sharp, closer to a cut stem than to sweet fruit. Pair that with black tea and dry wood, and you get the mood fans describe as a tea party on a forest floor.
So a good match needs two layers. It needs something sour and green on top, and something dry and woody underneath. A candle that delivers both will feel familiar, even when its note list looks different on paper.
That two-layer test is how we ranked the picks below.
The ranking, and the one reason behind it
Touch Grass ranks first because it covers both layers: sour green fruit on top, dry cedarwood below. Retail Therapy ranks second because it shares the black tea outright and adds tart berries, though it runs sweeter and juicier overall.
Both picks are 100% beeswax with wooden wicks and phthalate-free fragrance. What separates them is which half of Rhubarb Smoke you miss more, and which room you plan to burn it in.
1. Touch Grass: the closest match for tart fruit over dry wood
Picture a fig tree after a summer rain. You snap off a leaf and a bitter green sap beads on your fingers, while the bark beside it smells dry and warm. That contrast of wet green and dry wood is the heart of Rhubarb Smoke, and it is also the heart of our Touch Grass beeswax candle.
Touch Grass opens on galbanum, a plant resin that smells like the sap of a crushed stem. Its sharp green bite does the job rhubarb does in Rhubarb Smoke. It wakes up the top of the scent before anything sweet arrives.
Black currant sits right beside it. The berry has a sour, slightly leafy snap, so it pulls the same tart thread that rhubarb pulls. Fig then softens the top with a milky green note, the same fruit Rhubarb Smoke lists as wild figs.
The base is where the wood comes in. Cedarwood is dry and clean, like a freshly sharpened pencil, and it sits where birch and papyrus sit in Rhubarb Smoke. Amber and tonka bean warm it from below.
Orris, the root of the iris, adds a cool powdery note. Perfumers often pair orris with violet because the two share that character, which is why Touch Grass echoes the violet leaves in Rhubarb Smoke without listing them.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: Wooden (two on the 12 oz) | Fragrance: Phthalate-free. Notes: Fig, Black currant, Galbanum, Coconut, Davana, Cedarwood, Amber, Orris, Tonka bean | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: None
Best for: the living room, or any larger space where you light a candle most evenings. Choose the 12 oz Touch Grass ($65). Its two wooden wicks melt the full width of the jar, and a wider melt pool sends more fragrance into a bigger room.
2. Retail Therapy: the pick for the black tea and dark berry side
Steep a mug of strong black tea and leave the bag in a few minutes too long. The smell turns dry and dark, with a tannic edge you can almost taste. That is the note Rhubarb Smoke and our Retail Therapy beeswax candle share by name.
Retail Therapy sets that black tea under red and black currant, two berries with a sour snap. Peach and jasmine soften the middle. Amber and tonka bean warm the base, and anise adds a thin licorice thread that keeps the finish from going too sweet.
It lands juicier than Rhubarb Smoke. If the tea and the tart fruit were what you loved, this one will feel like home. If the green wood was the draw, stay with Touch Grass.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: Wooden (two on the 12 oz) | Fragrance: Phthalate-free. Notes: Red Currant, Black Currant, Jasmine, Peach, Black Tea, Amber, Anise, Tonka Bean | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: None
Best for: the bedroom, or a smaller room you light a few times a week. Choose the 5 oz Retail Therapy ($32). Its single wooden wick fills a bedroom without crowding it, and the tea and berry base reads soft at close range.
The biggest worry when you switch from a favorite is whether the new candle will fill the room. A verified buyer of Retail Therapy answered that in her own words:
“This scent has me in a chokehold. I burn it in my room and my living room and it fills my space SOOOOO nicely... Theres nothing I hate more than a candle that can't fill the room and baby this is NOT that. This candle permeates every corner of the room.”
Verified buyer
Side by side: how each pick lines up with Rhubarb Smoke
Here is the same two-layer test in one place. Read across a row to see which part of Rhubarb Smoke each candle carries.
| Touch Grass | Retail Therapy | |
|---|---|---|
| Wax | 100% beeswax | 100% beeswax |
| Wick | Wooden (two on the 12 oz) | Wooden (two on the 12 oz) |
| Note shared with Rhubarb Smoke | Fig | Black tea |
| Plays the role of rhubarb | Galbanum and black currant | Red and black currant |
| Plays the role of the woody base | Cedarwood and amber | Black tea, amber and anise |
| Overall mood | Green and woody | Juicy and tea-led |
| Burn time | 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) |
| Fragrance | Phthalate-free | Phthalate-free |
| Dyes | None | None |
| Where it is made | Hand poured in New York City | Hand poured in New York City |
| Best room | Living room, open spaces | Bedroom, smaller rooms |
The notes tell you which scent to pick. The wax tells you how much of that scent you will actually smell.
Why the wax decides how much of that scent reaches you
A candle only gives off as much fragrance as its melt pool releases. When the pool spreads to the edge of the jar, the whole surface sends scent into the room. When the wax melts only in the middle, much of the fragrance stays locked in the walls of wax around it.
Boy Smells pours its candles in a blend of coconut wax and beeswax. MBur candles use one ingredient, beeswax, with nothing blended in. Beeswax has the highest melting point of any candle wax, so the flame works through it slowly. That slow burn is why the 12 oz size runs 80+ hours.
The wooden wick matters too. Wood burns with a flat, wide flame, so it spreads heat across more of the surface and builds a fuller pool. It also crackles softly as it burns, a small fireside sound that suits a scent built on wood and green sap.
Then there is the fragrance itself. Many candles use toxic fragrance that contains phthalates, a group of chemicals added to help a scent linger. Every MBur scent uses phthalate-free fragrance with no chemical dyes, so what you smell is the fragrance and the faint honey warmth of the wax beneath it.
Beeswax also gives a flame with a light spectrum closest to natural sunlight. The glow on the wall reads warm and gold, which fits the slow, green evening mood that draws people to unique candle scents like Rhubarb Smoke in the first place.
With the wax settled, the next question is where the other well-known names fit.
Other names you will see in this search
Boy Smells started in 2016 as a candle-making experiment in its founders' Los Angeles kitchen. Its house style blends masculine and feminine notes without aiming at one gender. That is a big part of why Rhubarb Smoke shows up on lists of masculine scents and gender-neutral ones alike.
Diptyque makes a candle called Rhubarbe, built around the crisp, tangy side of the stalk. The Paris house is known for focused compositions that center on one material.
NEST New York is another luxury name that comes up in this search. It is a home fragrance brand with a wide scent library.
Touch Grass keeps the top spot because it pairs the Rhubarb Smoke mood with a candle you can read in one line: 100% beeswax, a wooden wick, phthalate-free fragrance, no dye, and hand poured in New York City.
Matching scent and size to the room you have
Your room should decide the size. Your memory of Rhubarb Smoke should decide the scent.
- Open living room or loft: Touch Grass in the 12 oz. Two wicks build a wide melt pool, and the green top carries across a big space.
- Bedroom: Retail Therapy in the 5 oz. The tea and berry base stays gentle at close range, which suits a room where you wind down.
- A room you light every night: either scent in the 12 oz. The 80+ hours carry you through weeks of evenings on one candle.
- Home office: Touch Grass in the 5 oz. The cedarwood and green sap keep the room feeling crisp while you work.
- Small bathroom or entry: the 5 oz of either scent. One wooden wick is plenty for a tight space.
Once the scent and size are set, two worries tend to come up. Both have clear answers.
But the smoke was the part I loved
Neither of our picks lists a smoke note, so here is what each one gives you in that spot. Touch Grass gets its dark, dry side from cedarwood and amber, and the wooden wick adds a quiet crackle as it burns. Retail Therapy gets its depth from black tea and anise, which together read darker than the fruit on top.
If you want even more shadow in the base, the FAQ below names the one other scent in our line built on a dry, dark note. That turns the question into which beeswax scent fits you best, since every option keeps the same clean wax and wooden wick.
But will beeswax feel subtle after Rhubarb Smoke?
Many fans rate Rhubarb Smoke as an intense scent, so this is a fair thing to wonder. The answer comes back to the melt pool. On the first burn, keep the candle lit until the melted wax reaches the edge of the jar.
Wax remembers that first pool and melts to the same width on every burn after. A full pool means the whole surface releases scent each time you light it. That is how the buyer above ended up with a candle that reaches every corner of her room.
Questions people ask before switching
Does Touch Grass actually smell like rhubarb?
Rhubarb is not on its note list. Galbanum and black currant carry the same sour green bite, and fig matches the wild figs in Rhubarb Smoke directly. That is why Touch Grass ranks first for anyone chasing the tart top of the original.
Which one is the more masculine scent?
Touch Grass reads drier and woodier, thanks to cedarwood and green galbanum. Retail Therapy reads juicier, with peach and jasmine in the middle. Both sit in the gender-neutral middle ground that made Rhubarb Smoke popular, and you can compare every note list in our beeswax candle collection.
Is there an MBur candle closer to the smoky, leathery side?
Room Service is the one we point people to. Its notes are Saffron, White Tea, Purple Peonies, Orchid, Tobacco, Vanilla, Almond Milk, Tonka Bean. Tobacco and saffron give it a dry, dark warmth that sits close to the leather in Rhubarb Smoke. It is our bestseller, and the Room Service beeswax candle suits a living room where you host.
How long do these beeswax candles actually burn?
The 5 oz size burns about 40 hours, and the 12 oz size burns 80+ hours. Beeswax melts at a higher temperature than other candle waxes, so the flame uses it up slowly. Snap off the charred tip of the wooden wick before each burn to keep the flame steady. Both Touch Grass and Retail Therapy come in both sizes.
Our pick: Touch Grass
Rhubarb Smoke works because it puts sour green fruit over dry wood. Touch Grass gives you that same structure in 100% beeswax, with fig straight from the Rhubarb Smoke list and galbanum and black currant in the role rhubarb plays.
Light it on a slow evening and the room feels green and calm, like a garden after rain with the windows open. The logic holds up too. Cedarwood sits where birch sat, and the two wooden wicks on the 12 oz spread that scent across a full living room.
One verified buyer described what switching to MBur felt like for her:
“They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out. I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good”
Verified buyer
If your Rhubarb Smoke jar is down to its last few burns, order now so the new candle arrives before the old one runs out.