The candle on this list that smells most like Twisted Peppermint shares only two notes with it, peppermint and vanilla. That short overlap is the reason its mint still reads cold in the second hour, long after most copies have turned into frosting. The order in which a scent fades matters more than matching every word on the label, and that idea decides how each pick here is ranked.
What customers say on Google
View on Google
Bath & Body Works first released Twisted Peppermint around 2006, and it comes back every holiday season. The classic notes read like a December candy counter: cool peppermint, sugared snow, vanilla buttercream, fresh balsam, and a hint of musk. Most fans looking for a match grab the first mint candle on the shelf and find it smells herbal or medicinal by the second night. The closer matches come from makers who build the mint to last, the way our pure beeswax candles, hand poured in New York City, pair each fragrance with a slow-burning wax.
Why this season's jar may not match the one you remember
The benchmark itself has moved. In recent buyer discussions, longtime fans pointed out that some Twisted Peppermint packaging no longer lists vanilla buttercream among the printed notes. Some of those fans say the scent now reads crisper and leans more toward balsam.
Bath & Body Works does not publish its formulas, so the full story stays inside the company. What you can see is the label, and on some batches the label changed. If the creamy candy-cane version is the one you fell for, buying the same name again each fall may not bring it back.
The second limit is the calendar. Twisted Peppermint is a seasonal release that shows up in autumn and leaves with the holiday shelf. Once it sells through, you wait until next fall. Even a jar from a good batch has one more problem, and it happens inside the wax.
The note that leaves first, and the one left behind
Perfumers sort fragrance notes by how fast they evaporate. Top notes are light molecules that reach your nose first and fade first. Base notes are heavy and slow, so they hang in the air long after the top has gone.
Peppermint is a classic top note. Vanilla and frosting-style sugar notes sit at the base. In a candle loaded with sweet base notes, the mint flashes off early and the sugar takes over the room.
That pattern matches the most common complaint buyers make about mint candles. The peppermint burns off too quickly, and what stays behind is a heavy, buttery sweetness that feels more like a bakery than a cold winter morning. Some copies have the opposite problem, a chemical toothpaste smell with no warmth under it.
A good peppermint candle balances both ends. It needs enough base to keep the mint grounded, and a slow enough burn that the mint is still rising when you walk back into the room. That gives you a short list of things to check before you buy.
Four checks for a peppermint candle that lasts past the first hour
- Peppermint, named on the label. Many winter or mint candles lean herbal, woodsy, or medicinal. If peppermint is missing from the notes, the cold candy-cane opening is a guess.
- A base that holds the mint without burying it. In Twisted Peppermint, balsam does this job. Cedar or a single vanilla note works the same way, with less sugar to drown out the top.
- A slow-burning wax. Beeswax has the highest melting point of any candle wax. A higher melting point means the flame uses up the wax more slowly, so the mint you like spreads across more evenings.
- A short fragrance list. Phthalates are chemicals some makers add to help a scent cling and spread. A phthalate-free, non-toxic fragrance keeps the ingredient list short, which matters for a candle you burn for hours in a closed winter room.
Run the usual holiday shelf through those four checks and most of it drops away. The five candles below are the ones worth your attention.
The 5 best candles that smell like Bath & Body Works Twisted Peppermint
We ranked these from the closest match to the original's cold-then-sweet arc down to the picks that borrow its holiday mood more loosely. The top spot goes to the candle whose notes fade in the same order Twisted Peppermint's do.
1. Sunday Reset by MBur: the closest match, and our pick
Think of the first cold Saturday in December. The tree is up and the radiator is ticking. You want the living room to smell the way that first Twisted Peppermint jar did years ago, a cold first breath with something warm settling in behind it.
Our Sunday Reset beeswax candle gives you that arc. Its notes are Peppermint, Clove, Cedar, Patchouli, Vanilla, Eucalyptus. Peppermint and eucalyptus open cold and sharp. Cedar stands in for the balsam in the original, and vanilla carries the sweetness underneath.
Clove and patchouli add a low warmth that keeps the mint from feeling thin. With one vanilla note in place of a stack of sugar notes, the peppermint stays in the room as the candle burns down.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, one on the 5 oz, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
Standout feature: cold peppermint over a cedar and vanilla base, the same cold-then-warm order as Twisted Peppermint.
Best for: the fan who loved the original's first breath and wants it to stay.
Size and price: the 12 oz, 80+ hour size, $65. Choose it for the living room you light most nights through winter, because its two wooden wicks spread the scent across a bigger space.
2. Slice of Life by MBur: the crispest, greenest mint
Now picture the kitchen on a December baking day. The oven has been on since noon, and the air is already heavy with butter and sugar. A sweet mint candle in that room just piles more sugar on top.
Our Slice of Life beeswax candle cuts through it. Its notes are Spearmint, Eucalyptus, Tomato Leaf, Anise, Mint. The mint and spearmint hit first, cold and green, with eucalyptus lifting the top.
Tomato leaf adds the sharp smell of a fresh-snapped stem, and anise brings a faint candy-shop sweetness. If you are one of the fans who says the newer Twisted Peppermint leans crisper, this is the mint that matches that memory.
Wax: 100% beeswax | Wick: wooden, one on the 5 oz, two on the 12 oz | Fragrance: phthalate-free | Burn time: 40 hours (5 oz), 80+ hours (12 oz) | Dyes: none
Standout feature: the coldest, least sugary mint on this list.
Best for: the kitchen during holiday baking, or anyone who finds most peppermint candles too sweet.
Size and price: the 5 oz, 40-hour size, $32. Pick it for the kitchen counter, because a smaller room needs only one wooden wick to fill it.
MBur scents carry well past the jar. One verified buyer put it this way:
"They smell up a WHOLE room during the burn & even a while after blowing them out. I won't buy other candles anymore, they're just that good"
Verified buyer
3. Goose Creek Peppermint
Goose Creek has built a following on candles with heavy throw. Its peppermint takes on the holiday theme come up often when fans trade Twisted Peppermint alternatives. The house style is bold, and the mint arrives loud and fast.
Standout feature: a loud, room-filling peppermint.
Who it suits: shoppers who want mint the moment the lid comes off.
4. Haus of Gloi Winter Divinity
Haus of Gloi is a small-batch maker with a devoted following. Winter Divinity pairs sweet vanilla with sharp peppermint and leaves out heavy balsam, so it reads lighter and closer to dessert.
Standout feature: a simple vanilla and peppermint pairing.
Who it suits: fans who think of Twisted Peppermint as a dessert first.
5. Aldi First Snow
Aldi's seasonal First Snow three-wick candle shows up in candle communities every winter as a match for that sweet, crisp winter-mint smell. It is a grocery-store seasonal, so it comes and goes with the holiday aisle.
Standout feature: a sweet, crisp winter mint.
Who it suits: shoppers picking up a holiday candle on the weekly grocery run.
All five picks side by side
| Pick | How the mint reads | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| 1. MBur Sunday Reset | Cold peppermint opening over cedar and vanilla | A living room you light most nights in winter |
| 2. MBur Slice of Life | Crisp, green mint with a touch of anise | A kitchen during holiday baking |
| 3. Goose Creek Peppermint | Bold, upfront peppermint | Fans of a loud mint |
| 4. Haus of Gloi Winter Divinity | Sweet vanilla with sharp peppermint, light on balsam | Fans of a dessert-style holiday scent |
| 5. Aldi First Snow | Sweet, crisp winter mint | Holiday grocery-run shoppers |
Sunday Reset holds the top spot because its notes fade in the same order the original's do, cold mint first and vanilla last. The beeswax underneath gives that arc 80+ hours on the large size.
Two things fans ask before they switch
"But my Twisted Peppermint fills the whole living room."
Room fill comes down to how wide the melt pool gets. The melt pool is the layer of liquid wax around the flame, and scent rises from its surface. Two flames melt a wider pool than one, so more fragrance reaches the air at once.
That is why the 12 oz Sunday Reset, with its two wooden wicks, is the size for an open living room. Let the first burn run until the pool reaches the edge of the jar. After that, the candle melts to the same width every time you light it.
"But I only want mint during the holidays."
Then size it for the season. Sunday Reset's cold peppermint and cedar work just as well on a gray January morning, the week you take the tree down.
If you light it mostly through the holiday weeks, or in a smaller room like a home office, the 5 oz size with one wooden wick fits that rhythm. Either way, the scent and the order it fades in stay the same.
Questions people ask about Twisted Peppermint alternatives
What candle smells the most like Twisted Peppermint?
Of the picks here, Sunday Reset is the closest. Its cold peppermint and eucalyptus opening sits over cedar and vanilla, which follows the same cold-then-sweet order as the original. You can read the full notes on the Sunday Reset candle page.
Is there a peppermint candle that's less sweet than Bath & Body Works?
Yes. Slice of Life leads with mint and spearmint, and its only sweet touch is a little anise. It reads crisp and green, which makes the Slice of Life mint candle a good fit for a kitchen or anyone who finds dessert candles too heavy.
What if I miss the sugary, bakery side of holiday candles?
Look at People Watching. Its notes are Lemon, Orange, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Clove, Nutmeg, Allspice, Ginger, so it smells like spice cake under a vanilla glaze. It has no mint, so the People Watching spice candle works best in a front room where guests come in from the cold, with a peppermint candle burning elsewhere.
How do I keep a peppermint candle smelling strong until the end?
Let the first burn run until the melt pool reaches the edge of the jar, so the candle does not tunnel. Snap off the charred tip of the wooden wick before each burn so the flame stays steady. A slow-burning wax helps too, which is why Sunday Reset in 100% beeswax keeps its mint across 80+ hours on the 12 oz size.
Our pick: Sunday Reset, for the room where you spend December
Twisted Peppermint works because of its order, cold mint first and sweetness last. Most copies lose the mint early because heavy sugar notes and a fast burn push it out of the room. The best match keeps that order and slows the whole burn down.
That candle is Sunday Reset in the 12 oz size. Light it in the living room on the first cold weekend and the air turns sharp and clear, then settles into cedar and vanilla while you wrap gifts on the floor. The proof is in the jar: peppermint and vanilla in the notes, two wooden wicks, 100% beeswax, and 80+ hours of burn.
"Candle burned slowly and was exactly the amount of hours the company said it would burn."
Verified buyer
Order it now if you want it lit for the first cold weekend of the season.
Get the 12 oz Sunday Reset beeswax candle for your living room, because it is the one that keeps the cold peppermint you loved going all season.
Related reading
